A few years ago, I wrote a news item about the FakeTV, which was a little box with LEDs that flicker, flash, and wane to simulate the look of a TV playing to make it look like someone is home. That little box simulated the light output of a 27″ TV, and that was just too small to simulate my big HDTV. I was looking on Amazon recently, and I found there was a new version of the FakeTV, and the FTV-11 Extra Bright Burglar Deterrent is designed to simulate the output of a 40″ TV. That’s closer to the size of my TV, so I placed my order from Amazon.
All images can be clicked for an enlarged view.
The Extra Bright FakeTV measures about 3″ X 2.5″ X 2.25″. It’s made of plastic, and it has a matrix 12 of “extra bright” LEDs seated in silvery reflectors. I couldn’t find any documentation saying what type of LEDs are used nor their light output. There’s a little computer inside that controls the LEDs to produce a constantly changing light show.
There’s a switch on the back of the FakeTV that can turn the device on or off, and it has two timer options, too. The light sensor on the back will turn the TV on at dusk, and the “tv” will play for four or seven hours before turning off. The instruction sheet recommended that in summer, when it gets dark later, you should choose the +4 hours option. In the winter when it gets dark early, you should choose the +7 option. You don’t have to worry about wasting a lot of energy even if you leave the FakeTV on constantly, because it is said to consume the same amount of power as a nightlight.
The instructions also warn that bright ambient light in the room can interfere with the light sensor. I was a bit worried about that, because I have a lamp on in the living room at dusk. It’s located across the room from the location near the front windows where I plan to position the FakeTV, so I hoped I’d be okay.
The bottom has a recessed area where you plug the included AC adapter.
Here’s the AC adapter and the instruction sheet.
I tried plugging it up just to see what it looked like from the front. It’s sitting on my fireplace mantle here, and I think that’s probably too far away from my windows to be clearly visible from the street.
Once I had confirmed that it worked, I was ready to move it to its permanent location.
I set it on the end table by the front windows of my living room. (The lamp seen here is not the lamp that will be on at night.) I selected +7 hours to start.
When you select a timer mode, some of the LEDs on the front light up to let you know which mode. The +4 lights up one red LED; the +7 lights up two blue LEDs.
The instructions say to aim the light from the FakeTV at “translucent shades, curtains, or blinds”. I don’t have any of those, but I do have those woven-reed Roman blinds. You can see through them a bit into the house at night, but it’s not a clear view in. The FakeTV is set below the level of the windowsill, so I don’t think anyone would be able to see the little box and know for sure what they are seeing.
We went out to dinner, and it was dark (and stormy) when we got home. I could see the light flickering away; it got dark around 8:30 or so, and it was about 9:00 then. The display through the windows wasn’t blindingly bright, but my HDTV doesn’t look a whole lot brighter than that through the window blinds. I couldn’t see the FakeTV box through the windows, only the light display.
The above video (taken with my iPhone 5) shows what the light display looks like inside my living room. It looks very much like the lights from a TV, with the lights changing colors or getting very bright or dim to simulate scene changes, or suddenly going off for a few seconds like a commercial break starting.
But what’s important is what it looks like from the outside. Our house is elevated in the front; it sits higher above the ground than a normal single-story house, and the bottom of the windows are about 5.5-ft above ground level. You couldn’t see the FakeTV box through the windows, even when standing pretty close to the house – like a burglar might if he were checking things out to decide if this was the house to rob. (And yes, it was raining out there. Such is my dedication to a good review – I’ll send my husband out in any kind of weather to get the video! 😉 )
The only problem I had with the FakeTV is that the +7 timer only gave me about 3 hours before turning off. It seemed to come back on by itself after all the lights were turned off in the living room, and it was still going when I got up this morning. That’s not good, but I never have planned to rely on the built-in timer. I intend to plug the FakeTV into a Belkin WeMo smart home automation switch, so that I can program on/off times for the FakeTV and so that I can connect remotely over WiFi or cellular and control it whenever I want.
Bottom line: I like the FakeTV FTV-11 Extra Bright Burglar Deterrent, but I won’t rely on its built-in timer. I think it really does give my house a “somebody’s home” look.
Product Information
| Price: | $39.95 |
| Manufacturer: | FakeTV |
| Retailer: | Amazon |
| Pros: |
|
| Cons: |
|
Gadgeteer Comment Policy - Please read before commenting
I’ve been using fake tv for years now. Great little gadget!
The “FakeTV” product is an inexpensive burglar deterent which simulates the flashing lights of a TV at night when you’re away from home. The product was a great idea, however, it’s a very cheaply made plastic product of poor quality and will completely stop working in a short amount of time.
The manufacturer, Hydreon Corporation, advertises a 3 Year Warranty but will not honor the warranty. Purchasing “FakeTV” is throwing your money in the garbage which is right where your “FakeTV” will be very soon.
Save yourself the time and money, stay away from “FakeTV”.
I dunno about the average “bad guy” but based on the video I see, I can visually see the LED’s “Ramping” in intensity. IC is probably using 8-16 steps in voltage with a very noticeable to me. The first thing that pops into my mind is not that it is a TV, but rather a set of LED Christmas lights on random.
The fades are very uniform and structured, not what you would expect to see on a TV. A TV would have a very smooth transition in intensities and colors. Perhaps a more foggy material over the leds (wax paper or frosted glass) would blend them together a bit better.
Thanks for reviewing.
Drew Baker commented that he saw the light intensity changing in steps. It will do that sometimes, because TV will sometimes, too. Picture, say, a set of progressively brighter scenes, or bright items appearing on the screen. Other times FakeTV will do smooth fades, with 256 levels, which is quite smooth. But if you don’t like what FakeTV is doing, wait a couple minutes, and it will be doing something different.
– Rein Teder
(Designer of FakeTV)
@Rain Teder Thanks for your comments.
I can see the stepping up in the video, too, but I don’t think someone who’s looking for a house to rob is going to be smart enough to analyze the light patterns and think that it looks more like LEDs ramping instead of a TV playing. I think they’re going to see the TV-like display and move on to another house.
“with 256 levels, which is quite smooth”
8bit Micro-controller huh. 😉 That probably is true. I did only see a small subset of the video. But then again I’m an engineer at heart, my other half hates watching movies with me because I catch these things. I either would make a horrible Robber or a great one. Not sure. Probably bad, since I would carefully disconnect whatever I was stealing and properly pack it to prevent damage.
“HURRY JUST GRAB THE COMPUTER”…wait, it’s shutting down properly. and I need to wrap the 100” LED TV in bubble wrap, and cross brace the back.
“FREEZE YOUR UNDER ARREST”
I have tried fake TVs and it is effective. But I think burglars already know what fake TVs are. If they are brave enough to check the window of the house, then that’s the bad side of it. Acquiring a security system still the most helpful decision.
Why not just actually leave your TV on, (and plug it into a timer so it shuts off after a while)?