EFIG.com\’s Palm V 8meg Upgrade Review

Most people won’t argue when I say that the Palm V is a very cool PDA. It looks cool,
it feels cool, it is just downright cool. But, there were loud complaints when it came
out. People moaned that it only had 2meg of RAM and that it could not be upgraded. I could
understand these complaints because I had been using an 8meg Palm III for quite awhile.
Moving backwards to 2meg was / is very difficult. But, I really liked the Palm V for its
size and its great new screen so I settled…

height="181" alt="palmv8-6.jpg (6236 bytes)"/>

Well, there is now some very good news for those of us that bought the Palm V but need more than 2meg of memory. A company called EFIG.com has created an upgrade process for the Palm V that will give it 8meg of RAM. You can either send your Palm V to them to upgrade, or you can buy a new upgraded unit directly from them. Using TRG’s FlashPro you can also take advantage of the 824k of Flash (I tested FlashPro with this upgraded unit and it worked just fine). Here’s a bit of background info on EFIG.com. EFIG has been in business since 1997. They have electronics experience since 1975. Other products that they work with are high speed digital design for consumer and industrial products with a special focus on signal integrity and electromagnetic emissions compatibility.  DVD players and MPEG set-top boxes.

Probably the biggest questions on everyone’s minds are "What does the unit look
like after the upgrade?", "How will the upgrade affect my warranty?", and
"How will it affect my battery life or performance?"

I’ll try to answer each of those questions in order.

"What does the unit look like after the upgrade?"
To upgrade the Palm V, it requires that the two metal shells that make up the case be
separated. These two shells are actually glued together, and not held in place with
screws. That was my main worry, what would the unit look like after it was taken apart and
then glued back together again.

When the unit arrived, I was anxious to carefully look it over. I was sure I’d find some scratches, dents or other signs that the unit had been opened. I was really surprised when I could find no real signs that the two shells had ever been separated. If you look at the picture on the right, you’ll see my non-upgraded Palm V is on top, and the upgraded unit is on the bottom. You can see that there is a slight space between the seam where the two shells meet. In the photos, the space look pretty noticeable but I actually didn’t notice it until I took these pictures.

height="267" alt="palmv8-1.jpg (13496 bytes)"/>

height="312" alt="palmv8-2.jpg (14581 bytes)"/>

Here’s another picture of the other side. You can see the space between the shells on this side as well. Although you can see this, the case does not flex or feel any less solid due to the upgrade. Also, the space between the seam is even and not wider or narrower at different points. I tried squeezing the shells together to see if I could close the gap but the case didn’t budge.

To the right is another view of the bottom seam. I didn’t show pictures of the sides or backs of the units because there wasn’t anything different between the two that I could see. Actually the only place where there was any difference between my non-upgraded unit and the upgraded unit was the bottom seam. As you can see below, I’ve included pictures of the top seams. In these pictures, my non-upgraded unit is on top and the upgraded unit is on the bottom. These seams are perfect. The only thing I found on the upgraded unit was a bit of dried glue on the edge of the seam. Using my fingernail, I was easily able to scrape it off. The power button and contrast button work just fine on the upgraded unit. As does the removal of the styli on either side of the unit.

height="239" alt="palmv8-5.jpg (9243 bytes)"/>

alt="palmv8-3.jpg (16523 bytes)"/> width="328" height="242" alt="palmv8-4.jpg (16015 bytes)"/>

I’d have to say that the workmanship on this unit is terrific. If I didn’t know any
better, I wouldn’t be able to really tell the difference between the upgraded unit and my
unit. If that is your main worry about having the upgrade performed on your Palm V, I
would let you fears rest.

"How will the upgrade affect my warranty?"
The upgrade will void your warranty from 3com. EFIG.com will be supplying their own
warranty. I don’t have any details on this yet.

"How will it affect my battery life or performance?"
Unfortunately, I have only had the upgraded unit for a few hours and must return it soon.
As a result, I won’t have the time to do any real battery testing. EFIG.com has done some
of their own extensive testing. They found that  "active use" battery life
was extended.  But the downside was that an upgraded device will only retain memory
for 41 days compared to 100 days for a standard PalmV when that unit is turned off and not
in use.  You can find more details of their testing at their site.

As for performance, I can’t tell any difference between the two units. They both are
just as snappy at opening and running programs. I ran the same benchmark program that I
used in my Palm V review and came up with the same results
+/- one second.

So, if you have a Palm V should you upgrade it? That really depends on your typical
memory usage. The first thing I would do if you are filling the 2meg is to buy FlashPro (this software will let you use 824k of unused
flash memory). Then if you are still running out of memory, I would definitely consider
this upgrade. I am personally going to have my unit upgraded after seeing the great job
that was done on the review unit that I’ve had.

Price: $249 to upgrade your existing Palm V / $649 for
upgraded brand new Palm V / $40 for optional warranty

Pros:
Upgrades your Palm V to 8meg of RAM
You can’t tell physically the difference between the upgraded model and the non-upgraded
model.
They plan a fast turn around time for the upgrades. In on Monday and out on Thursday.

Cons:
Requires you to send in your Palm V to be upgraded.
Will void your Palm warranty. EFIG.com is preparing a warranty of their own.

Tagged as: Palm, Parts

If you don't want to miss new postings, please consider subscribing to our RSS feed.