The Gadgeteer

Summary

Gadget Review

Advertisement
Review at a glance

Manufacturer: EagleTec

Price: $25.00

Pros:
  • Compact way to use SD cards in CF slots
Cons:
  • Does not have a ridge along the top edge to help with extraction
Categories: More reviews like this one:

[discuss this review (0 comments so far)]

Advertisement
Advertisement

EagleTec SD to CF II Card Adapter

Gadgeteer Hands On Review by Julie

June 10, 2005

Product Requirements:
Device:
Any device that can accommodate a Type II CF card

I live by the Boy Scout motto: Be Prepared. I have a zippered pouch in my gear bag that has all kinds of little adapters and tools. Things like the Victorinox CyberTool and FlexUSB adapter. I just found another adapter that will be taking up permanent residence in that pouch: The EagleTec SD to CF card adapter, which I received from Brando.

There isn't anything really mysterious about this adapter. It is basically a CF Type II shell, with a slot that an SD card can plug into.

Above you can see a regular run of the mill Lexar SD card plugged into the side of the adapter. When fully inserted, the card's outside edge is flush with the end of the adapter.

You might wonder if this adapter has any effect on file transfer speeds. I did a quick test where I copied a folder of 111mb from my PC to an SD card and then back again. Times for that test were 40 seconds and 6 seconds. Then I did the same test with the SD card inserted into the adapter. The results were 49 seconds and 6 seconds.

Above you can see the adapter plugged into the Dell x50v Pocket PC. It fits perfect and works perfect. Unfortunately, we all know that nothing really is perfect. That is true of this product too. The only problem with the EagleTec SD to CF adapter is the fact that the edge of the adapter does not have a lip. As such, you will play havoc trying to remove it from any device that does not have an eject button. After inserting it into the x50v, I had to use some needlenose pliers to pull it out of the slot. Grrrrrr....  That said, I'm still keeping it in my gear bag. I'll just remember to keep a small pair of pliers in there too!

 

Price: $25.00

Pros:
Compact way to use SD cards in CF slots

Cons:
Does not have a ridge along the top edge to help with extraction

Advertisement
Discussion (0 comments)
Post A Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Login:
Password:

Note: Forum accounts do not work for the new comment system. You may create an account by visiting this page.

Gadgeteer Forums

Post your comments here on the EagleTec SD to CF II Card Adapter review.

http://www.the-gadgeteer.com/eagletec-sd-to-cf-adapter-review.html

Just click the POST REPLY button on this page.

posted June 10, 2005 23:25:55 PM by Julie

great product.. Is SD still cheaper then CF?

I heard that MMC is going to make a major comeback... something like 10-20GB MMCs cards within the next couple of years..

F.

posted June 12, 2005 01:52:02 AM by flamaest

flamaest:

Historically, SD has been more expensive than CF because it is a newer technology. These days the prices of the two are pretty close to equal.

posted June 12, 2005 08:21:30 AM by Julie

You have not commented at all on speed. Is a SD card in the CF adapter much slow, or equally fast as in the SD slot?

Surur

posted June 13, 2005 18:23:38 PM by Surur

Surur:

I did a quick test where I copied a folder of 111mb from my PC to an SD card and then back again. Times for that test were 40 seconds and 6 seconds. Then I did the same test with the SD card inserted into the adapter. The results were 49 seconds and 6 seconds. I'll go update the review with this info.

posted June 13, 2005 18:55:54 PM by Julie

[ 18 more comments on this review -- join the discussion ]