Wolf Gourmet 2 Slice Toaster Review

We use affiliate links. If you buy something through the links on this page, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Wolf 1 scaled e1595110644609

REVIEW – Pre-COVID, my breakfasts during the workweek usually consisted of a protein bar, drive through breakfast taco, or nothing at all.  Since I have been home, I have been trying to vary my breakfast habit and cook a bit more.  No, I am not on any kind of Keto diet as I don’t think I could ever give up bread, but I do enjoy some scrambled eggs and a single slice of toast, or a bagel with light cream cheese.  So when the chance came to review the Wolf Gourmet 2 Slice Toaster I jumped at it thinking it would really step up my bagel and toast game.  Let’s see how it did!

What is it?

The Wolf Gourmet 2 Slice Toaster is exactly what it says it is.  It is a two-slice maximum toaster.

What’s in the box?

Wolf 2 scaled e1595110654323

  • Two slice toaster
  • Small single piece of paper saying the toaster uses radiant heat and that while toasting, not all heating elements may be glowing.   More on this later.
  • A thank you card for purchasing the toaster
  • Owner’s use and care guide

Hardware specs

  • Shade selector dial with seven settings allows for precise control of toast color from light to dark.  Settings are 1-7
  • Extra-wide slots accommodate a full variety of bread.
  • Self-centering bread guides toast thin or thick slices to ensure even browning.
  • After toasting, bread is automatically raised to the ideal height for access.
  • 7″ x 12″ x 8 1/2″ high.
  • 6.5 lb.
  • 900W
  • Keep Warm setting runs for three minutes after toasting is complete.
  • Bagel setting toasts the inside and warms the outside.
  • Frozen setting for one-step toasting of frozen bread, waffles and French toast.
  • Bread lifters offer quiet operation.
  • Slide-out crumb tray for easy cleaning.
  • Stainless-steel and die-cast construction.
  • This product is intended for use in the United States and Canada and is built to United States electrical standards.
  • Made in China.

Design and features

Wolf 3 scaled e1595110664393

I wanted to start out this review by showing you a picture of the Wolf toaster next to our KitchenAid two-slice toaster.  Right away you can see the Wolf is a bigger appliance.  It really looks like it could be sitting in a commercial kitchen.  If your kitchen has a lot of stainless appliances, this toaster would fit right in.

Wolf 4 scaled e1595110674321

I took the picture above to show you the buttons on the top of the toaster along with a view of the bread slots.  The toaster is wider than my existing toaster.  That is because the toasting slots themselves are wider than my old toaster.  Bagels in my old toaster had to be forced down to get them to toast.  No matter what I put in this toaster, it all seemed to fit with no issues and slid down on its own when I pushed down the lever.

The first button on the left is the cancel button.  Pressing that, stops the toaster and ejects the bread to a level in which you can easily pull it from the toaster.  The keep warm button is a nice feature in that when it is pressed before or during toasting, it will continue to keep your bread warm even after the toasting is done.  I find that very handy if I am continuing to cook other things.  It beeps at you about every 15 seconds to remind you that you have something in the toaster.  The frozen button can also be selected at any time and tells the toaster you have put a frozen item in the toaster.  The last button for bagel tells the toaster to only turn on the inside facing heating elements.  This prevents the outside of the bagel from getting toasted.

Wolf 5 scaled e1595110684994

Wolf 6 scaled e1595110695186

The picture above is showing the right side of the toaster as you face the front.  On the bottom right is the crumb tray.  It easily slips out and in to allow for cleaning out of the bread crumbs.

Wolf 7 scaled e1595110705458

This picture is showing the air vents that are on the top of both the left and right sides of the toaster.  Hot air comes out, but not hot enough to damage anything sitting on the side of the toaster.  I had a blender to the right of the toaster and it was never impacted by the vent.

Wolf 8 scaled e1595110714778

I took the picture above to show you have the bread slots squeeze in to hold slices of bread.  This picture has a very thin slice of sourdough bread and it does have it nicely centered within the toaster.


Wolf 9 scaled e1595110730470

Now we come to the part of the review where I am a bit disappointed.   I will be the first to admit that due to the cost of this toaster, I expected the best-toasted bread ever!  What I got, however, left me wanting.  The first picture above is a regular piece of toast.  The toast on the left was toasted by our old toaster and the one on the right by the Wolf.  Reading the manual, it says I can use any value from 1-7.  I put it on 5 like my old toaster.  You can see that it did not toast as evenly as my old toaster.  You can also see where I had a couple of ‘hot spots’ on the bread.

Wolf 10 scaled e1595110746774

Wolf 11 scaled e1595110756404

I decided to try some bagels next.   These pictures are of two different bagels after toasting.  The user manual mentions using settings 5-7 for bagels.  I found level 5 way too dark for my taste, and these pictures are with bagels at level 4.  You can see how unevenly they toasted.

Wolf 12 scaled e1595110766323

Wolf 13 scaled e1595110775237

I took the above pictures to show you how the heating elements glow.  The bagel setting is on, so only the inside elements are heating which is how it is supposed to work.  If you notice on the right picture, the elements in the top and middle do not appear to be heating up.  Remember that small piece of paper in the ‘what’s in the box’ section?  It says that is normal.  However, I did find that the spots where the heating elements are not glowing are where the bagel was less toasted.

Wolf 14 scaled e1595110784721 Wolf 15 scaled e1595110794224

I tied the frozen setting with some frozen waffles of a popular well-known brand.   The first picture is one side and the second is the backside.  I had the frozen button lit and the bagel button was off.  Notice how one side was significantly toasted more than the other.

Wolf 16 scaled e1595110806304

I am noticing over time that the toaster seems to be getting a bit more even in its toasting.  It may require a break-in period.  I would also like to note, that bagels are often uneven with some parts being wider and thicker than others.  That could have caused some of my uneven toastings.   I will be sure to update this review in about six months and let you know if it has been toasting more evenly.

What I like

  • I love how it brings the bread up to the proper level to be removed.  My old toaster would sometimes fail in that aspect.
  • It really is a gorgeous appliance
  • It has really wide slots to handle large pieces of bread.
  • The keep-warm and frozen features are pretty nice.

What needs to be improved

  • At least initially, the toaster does not seem to do even toasting.  There are some hot and cool spots on toast and bagels.
  • Really expensive for a toaster.

Final thoughts

If you are looking for an appliance that will make you look like you know what you are doing in the kitchen and have the money to do it, this is the toaster for you. (Think Porsche in your garage!)  However, if you are more practical and want a good toaster without breaking the bank, I think there may be better choices out there for you.  I honestly do not think I would spend my own money on this particular toaster.

Price: $299.95
Where to buyWilliams Sonoma and Amazon
Source: The sample of this product was provided by Subzero – Wolf

3 thoughts on “Wolf Gourmet 2 Slice Toaster Review”

  1. Gadgeteer Comment Policy - Please read before commenting
  2. It blows me away that you can get better toasting results with a $20 toaster from Walmart than a $300 luxury-brand toaster!

    You’d think that Wolf would take the time to redesign the heating elements so it performs better!

    I was considering dipping my toe into the Wolf product line beginning with this toaster, but the results have definitely changed my mind. In fact, looking at others’ reviews of the same model shows similar uneven toasting results. Bummer, but no thanks.

  3. Did the toaster ever break in and toast evenly? This is the 4th toaster I’ve bought, just trying to find one that toasts and so far I’m disappointed. I bought the 4 slice and one side toasts more unevenly than the other, but neither produces good toast so far. Somehow the right side looks like toast and is just a little too toasted on the outside, but too soft in the middle! These are pretty thin bread slices too.

    On the left side, it’s completely uneven. We tried bagels that had been frozen and eggos.

    I paid for this because I read a review that said it was the last toaster you’ll need to buy, but it’s very close to going back. Did yours improve? Why can’t any company produce an appliance that will make toast anymore? It’s absurd. The one I had for a decade managed it, but the replacements must all be made in the same factories.

    I wish I knew which $20 one works. I’m seriously concerned some of these new toasters might burn the house down.

  4. I’m very disappointed in the center heating elements not providing even toasting. This should be basic for such an expensive toaster. It is very disappointing. There should be a button to accomplish this. Wolf should provide a fix. I would not get another Wolf product

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *