Destinator Personal Navigation System for Pocket PC (Installed in Vehicle with ProClip System) Review

Product Requirements:
PC with a Pentium processor (90MHz or
faster), Microsoft Windows 95 or a later version of Windows, 32MB RAM, 4x or
faster CD-ROM drive
Device:
Mobile Pocket PC Device, 32MB RAM and a 96MB
external memory card or 64MB RAM

It wasn’t long ago that I was posting a diary
entry telling how I wanted my next vehicle to have a factory installed GPS
system. An interesting discussion ensued, both on the
Gadgeteer
BB and in my private e-mail. I had just bought my SUV about 6 months before
I decided that GPS was a necessity, so it wasn’t exactly practical to trade my
Ford Expedition in anytime soon. More realistically, I needed to find an
after-market GPS solution. Since I just so happened to have an IPAQ 5455 that
wasn’t getting daily use, I knew that a Pocket PC based scenario would be the
ideal set-up for me.

I have to admit that before I began writing this review, I had zero
experience with GPS navigation. While I can be pretty handy with an atlas and I
have never been afraid to ask for directions, the next logical step had just
never occurred. Enter the Destinator
Personal Navigation System.

Believe it or not, Julie just happened to have an unopened Destinator
sitting at her house; it was something that she had requested for review, but
hadn’t gotten to yet. After hearing how cool I thought it would be to have GPS
in my vehicle, she decided to kill two birds with one stone: she got me
to write the review, and she made my day. Pretty cool, huh?
☺

When I received the Destinator package, I was a
little bit surprised at it’s simplicity. It turned out to be a matter of
installing some software and maps, then just plugging the cables in. Hey, anyone
could do this!

Inside the box was a small black GPS antenna
receiver with attached cables, a cigarette lighter adapter/charger with attached
cables, as well as the CD-ROM which contained the Destinator software,
NAVTECH® maps detailed to the house level,
embedded points of interest (POI) in the maps, a user manual and a tutorial.
There was also a canvas drawstring sack for storing the system when I wasn’t
using it, so of course – I use it for something else entirely. Unfortunately,
there was no method included for mounting or holding my iPAQ when I was using
the system in my SUV.

Although I have access to various vehicle mounting systems, I wanted one that
was as professional in appearance and as integrated as possible – all things
considered. Checking the

Accessories and Complementary Products portion of the
Buy
Destinator page, revealed a picture of an integrated solution and a link to

Proclip USA. Here, I found exactly what I would need to complete my GPS
installation! Entering my vehicle’s year, make and model, I found a cradle that
would hold my iPAQ while integrating the charger/interface cable of the
Destinator system. Another search revealed a clip that would hold the cradle in
one of two places: either to the side of the AC vent or to the side of my center
console. I chose the clip for the vent, as I wanted the system to be where
either my passenger or I could easily hear or glance at it.

Now, before I go any further with this review, I will mention that it isn’t
safe to drive while playing with your GPS. Most are adults here, and I assume
that we all know this. With that said, one of the ProClip’s features that
impressed me the most was that the cradle holding your Pocket PC will actually
swivel so that your passenger can easily be your navigator if you are traveling
somewhere tricky. Of course, the Navigator will also call out turns for you – so
that also helps you keep your eyes on the road and your head where it needs to
be when you are traveling alone.

Since I would have to wait at least a week before I had the ProClip system,
and since I already had the Destinator and the iPAQ – I figured that in the
interim I should go ahead and set it all up. So, popping the included CD-ROM in
my laptop, I was greeted with this screen allowing me to begin…

Installing the Destinator software and maps was quick – and I was really
thankful that I already had a 512MB Compact Flash card and
Silver Slider 3 that I could use with my
iPAQ. The Loader was able to tell me my available storage locations…

Previously, I had emptied my iPAQ of everything but my Contacts, and I had
also installed a 128MB SD card. When I ran the Destinator program, it easily
found both of my cards and the empty memory in my iPAQ – but after transferring
a couple of maps via iPAQ in cradle, I realized that it would be a lot faster to
use my Keyspan Media Reader,
instead. Picking the maps to install was a matter of clicking the buttons of the
ones I wanted, up to the limit of the memory card I was filling at the time.       

I probably loaded more maps than I will most likely need – but I always like
to be over-prepared.

With my maps installed, I couldn’t help myself; I had to go test out the GPS
in my driveway. Never mind that I didn’t yet have a cradle, never mind that I
wasn’t actually going anywhere – I just wanted to see it work…and after
plugging in the power adapter, putting the GPS module on my dash, and after
attaching the charger/interface cable – it did. I was looking at my
home/position laid out in a map grid with street names and everything. Honestly,
this was a true Zen moment.

But since I still didn’t have a way to mount my Destinator enabled iPAQ
properly, I reluctantly put everything away.

About a week later, I received the ProClip system in the mail. For those of
you that drive a Ford Expedition, these are the part numbers for the items that
I ordered: 848534 – the Compaq iPAQ 3800/3900 (and 5400, might I add) holder
with tilt swivel, and 852693 – the vent clip for 1999-2002 Expeditions. If you
drive a different vehicle or use a different PDA, your cradle and mount will
most likely look a little bit different.

This is the tilt/swivel mounting cradle package, which included the cradle
itself, a bracket to enclose the Destinator’s charger/interface cable, two
very important and very tiny plastic t-bar thingies (for lack
of a better description), and two screws.

  
      

    

The mounting kit included a bracket that would fit between my stereo and AC
vent, and a pry-tool for squeezing the bracket into such a tight spot…

   
   

Since I now had everything I needed to become GPS enabled, I gathered up all of
my goodies including a set of screwdrivers, went outside and got to work.

The first order of business was to attach the charging/interface cable to the
cradle. I quickly figured out which way the cable would need to face so that the
iPAQ would properly attach, then laid it in the cradle and attached the
cover-plate. But I forgot something! In my haste, I didn’t put the little t-bar
"thingies" in, which meant that once I installed my iPAQ it would be installed
for life. While that might be acceptable for some, I knew there would be
times when I would need to remove my iPAQ, so I had to back up and install the
t-bars. They keep the sides of the iPAQ plug compressed at all times so that
while the iPAQ will sit securely in the cradle, you can easily slide it in and
out of place.

  
  

With the cradle ready, I next needed to install the mounting bracket. Using
the pry-tool, I was able to jimmy the plate in between the vent and my stereo.
Next, I unscrewed the swivel portion of the cradle (the big middle screw) and
used the two smaller screws to attach that plate to the mounting bracket. Once
that was firmly attached, I reattached the swivel base to the cradle.

   
    
   

Next, I put the Destinator GPS module on my dash, and attached the suction
cup that would keep it from sliding anywhere…

I plugged the power/charging cord into my lighter, installed my iPAQ, and
Viola – my home/position, in all its mapped glory!

   
   
  

Granted, this is not a factory in-dash system, but I think it looks pretty
good for what it is!

  

After the installation, all that remained was to actually try out the
system…

For those of you that are as clueless as I was, I am going to give you a
short-course on what GPS is, and how it works. For those of you that are
well-versed in this subject, take a moment and talk amongst yourselves…

The first GPS (Global Positioning System) satellite was launched in the late
1970s for military use only. This allowed better navigation and better weapons
aiming. Like all cool gadgets, it wasn’t long before civilians heard about the
technology, and they wanted it for their own personal and recreational use. The
first consumer products showed up in the 1980s, and in 1984, President Ronald
Reagan declared that a portion of GPS satellites capabilities would be made
available to the civilian market. You can read a bit more about GPS history
here.

It would be best if I now
quote from an excellent article that I found on the history of GPS,
published on the New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology’s
web site, to explain the following: "Each
of the GPS satellites transmits radio signals. GPS receivers pick up these
signals and measure the distance to a satellite by multiplying the speed of the
signal by the time it takes the signal to get there. The speed of the signal is
the speed of light and the time is encoded within the signal. The satellites
also send information on their exact location.

In order to find longitude, latitude, and altitude, four satellites are
needed. If a measurement is taken using just one satellite, then all that is
known is that the receiver is on the surface of a sphere with radius equal to
the distance to the satellite. If two satellites are used, then the receiver
must be on the surface of both spheres which is the intersection of the two
spheres or the perimeter of a circle. If a third satellite is used, then the
location of the user is narrowed down to the two points where the three spheres
intersect. Three measurements are enough for land receivers since the lower of
the two points would be selected. But when in the air or space, four satellites
are needed: the intersection of all four spheres will be the receiver’s
location. When more than four satellites are used, greater accuracy can be
achieved."

That should give you an overview of GPS, now let’s talk about the Destinator
Navigation System in particular…

According to the Destinator
FAQ, their product is the best because: "Destinator™ is a fully featured
GPS navigation system. As opposed to other GPS mapping systems, Destinator™
tells you not only where you are, but also how to reach your destination in the
most efficient manner. Secondly, the cost is lower than most dedicated in
vehicle navigation systems. Destinator™’s advanced navigation algorithms and
superior map-processing technology makes Destinator a true car navigation system
with features rivaling and surpassing those of permanently installed systems at
a fraction of the cost. With Destinator™, you do not need to pay any additional
monthly charges or fees. Third, it is very portable. Destinator™ can easily be
moved from one vehicle to another. Fourth, your PDA or laptop will now provide
you with all the functionality of a Pocket PC PDA or laptop in addition to the
navigation capabilities. Fifth, Destinator™ uses the highest quality maps
provided by Navigation Technologies. These are the same maps used by FedEx,
OnStar, Mercedes-Benz, Lexus, Jaguar and Porsche just to name a few. Finally,
proprietary patented compression technology puts a larger area of the country
onto the PDA at one time, than is possible with any other product."

All of this sounded great to me – now for the road test!

The first screen you see when you power up Destinator (other than the one
where you enter your activation code) is the following…

This is just a friendly reminder that if you are going to be foolish enough to use the program while you are driving, then it’s your own fault when you wreck.

Now is the time to do some setting up.

Hitting the Menu button reveals a series of choices. First you should hit Switch Map to make sure that you are in the correct area. Once the correct map is selected, your streets will match your GPS position. Having an incorrect map with a correct GPS position can create some predictable problems. Next, entering Settings allows you to set up all of your preferences..

.

Here are some of the choices you have, and the screens you will encounter…

 
 
 
 

After setting up my preferences, I decided to key in my HOME position so that
it would always be easy to find my way back from "wherever." To do this, I just
hit the Destination button in Menu, and got this screen…

Hitting Contacts allows Destinator to access the addresses in your Pocket Outlook Contacts file. You choose the contact you want, in this case – myself, and then you hit the Book icon in the bottom left of the screen. This allows you to save the address as a Favorite. I designated mine as Home, and so now I know that I can at least get back from anywhere I have driven to. ☺

When you have an address that you need help finding, you hit the
Destination button, then choose the way that you would like to enter the
address. My usual way is by hitting the City -> Street button.

After entering the City, you will enter the street, then the number. It will make your life much easier if you remember that you only enter the pertinent information for each tab. In other words, don’t enter the house number you are trying to get to while on the Street tab. I wouldn’t mention this if I hadn’t learned it the hard way… Once your destination is entered, you hit Go!, and your map will be created – and your route will be clearly marked with a blue and white line…unless you decide you want to use a view that really makes the Destinator software stand out…

Check it out! 3D trip routing! This is easily my favorite view. While it doesn’t show you street names, it does offer a block by block view of where you are and where you are going. A convenient red arrow marks the spot when you get to your destination. This view is especially handy when you are in areas that have more than just one simple road. Your route is highlighted in bright red, and your PDA will announce to you when your turns are approaching.

The Destinator software is easy to use – even for a beginner like me – and it
is intuitive. The entries make sense, and the directions are easy to understand.
Just a few of the pleasant surprises I have received from the system can be seen
in the following screens:

On the left, you can see the highway that crosses the bridge that straddles my family’s ranch. The two lines that cross the highway are the caliche roads that enter each place. I truly never expected to see our ranch roads on my iPAQ. WOW! On the right, you can see another rural snapshot. The detail of the roads and even what essentially amounted to people’s driveways just amazed me! One more thing that I have been impressed with, is that it seems as if there is almost no lag at all between where I really am and where the GPS says I am. Every now and then, it may lag for just a second or two by what amounts to a couple yards, but it seems to quickly correct itself. I mainly notice it on sharp turns in twisty neighborhoods – and it does not happen all the time.

I also think that it is quite cool that not only can you see where you are on the map, you can also see where you are in relation to everything. Pushing the GPS Status button shows you how many satellites you are receiving from (in this case, six), as well as your longitude, latitude, velocity and altitude. As you can see, I had accidentally hit the metric button – these items will also display in standard US.

With that said, there are a couple of little quirks that I have found while
using the system over the past couple of weeks. I am not sure exactly what
brings them on, and they are not really even annoying enough for me to consider
them as cons:

This happened today as I was driving home from the ranch. All of a sudden, according to my iPAQ, I was driving in someone’s pasture…but I wasn’t! After about a hundred yards or so, I was "back on the road." Another little glitch I have seen is that every now and then I will hit a dead spot – usually on the highway between San Angelo and Eden. When this happens, the screen will just lock up, and it takes a soft reset before I am back in business. Since it always seems to happen in the same place, I think that it has something to do with the way the satellites must be aligning – maybe I happen to lose one for just a moment or something.

One of the Destinator features that I had the most fun with was the one that made my PDA announce we were going "over the speed limit." Personally, I think it is amazing that the software knows this! My husband was going crazy hearing the speed warnings, as he is notorious for his lead foot. Unfortunately, the external speaker on the iPAQ 5455 is so lame that it is near impossible to hear the alert voice when the radio is on.

After using the Destinator Personal Navigation System with the ProClip
Vehicle Mount for the last couple of weeks, I can tell you that I am now a
GPS Junkie! I am going to have to add a product such as the
irock! so that I can actually hear the
directions over my stereo speakers, though. Of course, the big "gotcha" with
that idea is that I will not be able to listen to the radio at the same
time…ah well. It’s always something, right?

Prices: $329 for the Destinator Personal Navigation
System, $49.95 for the ProClip cradle, and $29.95 for the ProClip dashboard
mounting plate
Add $250 – $700 for the PDA to use with it

Pros:
Less expensive than a factory GPS system
Can be moved from vehicle to vehicle
Maps are highly accurate
GPS is real time with little to no lag
ProClip is sturdy and swivels for easy passenger viewing
ProClip is made for your PDA and vehicle, and fits interior accordingly

Cons:
It’s still expensive – but then, that is relative isn’t it?