Buy the M5
Buy the MacBook Air with M5. The 13-inch model is the pick for most buyers at Apple’s current starting price of $1,299, with 16GB of unified memory and a 512GB SSD. Buy the 15-inch M5 at $1,499 if this laptop is your only screen. Buy the MacBook Air with M4 only if you find one at $799 or less and 256GB of storage covers your work.
Skip the M4 at any higher price, and skip this upgrade entirely if you already own an M4 Air. The chassis did not change. The storage, the chip, and the wireless did, and storage decides it.
Price: From $1,099
Where to Buy: Apple MacBook Air M5 15-inch, 16GB / 512GB Starlight | Amazon
The M4 sets the bar the M5 has to clear
Start with the older machine, because most readers weighing this choice own one or can still find one on a clearance shelf. The MacBook Air with M4 runs a 10-core CPU with four performance cores and six efficiency cores, an 8-core or 10-core GPU, a 16-core Neural Engine, and 120GB/s of memory bandwidth. It starts at 16GB of unified memory and a 256GB SSD, configurable to 24GB or 32GB of memory and up to 2TB of storage.
Its original starting price was $999 for the 13-inch model and $1,199 for the 15-inch model. Apple no longer lists the M4 Air for sale, so an M4 in a store today is retailer stock, and its price is a clearance price, not an Apple price. Judge it that way.
That is still a fast laptop. Web work, documents, email, video calls, and light photo editing do not tax it. The M4 was never the problem in this comparison. The problem is the 256GB SSD at the base, in a machine with no storage upgrade path after purchase. A buyer who fills that drive in the second year owns the consequence for the life of the laptop.
Double the storage is the whole argument
The M5 Air starts at 512GB and configures up to 4TB, against 256GB and 2TB on the M4. Apple also rates the M5 SSD at twice the read and write performance of the previous generation. At the original list prices, the step from the $999 M4 to the $1,099 M5 cost $100 and doubled the base storage. That trade was already worth taking.
Apple has since raised the M5 starting price to $1,299 for the 13-inch model and $1,499 for the 15-inch model. Price any M4 you find against those current figures. A clearance M4 at $799 or less saves real money against a $1,299 M5 and earns its place for light work.
A clearance M4 at $900 or $999 saves less, gives up half the base storage, and gives up the newer chip and wireless with it. That is a bad trade dressed as a discount.
The 512GB base also changes the second purchase most Air buyers used to make on day one. A photographer or video editor working from the internal drive gets room for a working library before an external drive enters the bag. Buy external storage for backup and archive, not because the new laptop arrived already tight on space.

The chip gain is real, and it is concentrated
The M4 chip is the baseline here, so measure the M5 against it directly. The M5 keeps a 10-core CPU and an 8-core or 10-core GPU, renames the four high-end CPU cores as super cores, moves memory bandwidth from 120GB/s to 153GB/s, puts a Neural Accelerator inside each GPU core, and adds a third-generation ray-tracing engine. The 16-core Neural Engine carries over from the M4.
Apple’s own tests put the M5 at up to four times the AI performance of the M4, up to 1.9 times the performance in Topaz Video AI enhancement, and up to 1.5 times the performance in both Blender ray tracing and Affinity image processing. Those gains land in on-device AI work, 3D rendering, and image and video processing.
They do not change how either machine handles a browser, a spreadsheet, or a video call. Both chips clear that work with room to spare, and no buyer should pay the M5 premium for email.
Wireless follows the same pattern. The M4 uses Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 5.3. The M5 uses Apple’s N1 wireless chip for Wi-Fi 7, Bluetooth 6, and Thread networking. On a Wi-Fi 7 network, the M5 is the Air that can use it. On the Wi-Fi 6E network most homes and offices still run, this upgrade sits ready and changes nothing today. It is a runway gain, not a day-one gain, and the verdict does not rest on it.
What did not change, and why that cuts both ways
Put the two 13-inch machines side by side and you cannot tell them apart. Both use the same 13.6-inch Liquid Retina display at 2560 by 1664, 500 nits, P3 wide color, and True Tone. Both carry MagSafe 3, two Thunderbolt 4 ports, and a 3.5mm headphone jack. Both use a 53.8Wh battery rated at up to 18 hours of video streaming and up to 15 hours of wireless web.
Both carry the same 12MP Center Stage camera with Desk View and 1080p video, the same four-speaker system on the 13-inch model, a three-mic array, and Touch ID. Weight barely moves, from 1.24 kg on the M4 to 1.23 kg on the M5.
Familiarity is the comfort and the cost here. Your M4 case, sleeve, and desk setup carry straight over to the M5, and the M5 works with the same iPhone, iPad, and accessories the M4 worked with. The cost side is just as plain: nothing about the screen, the keyboard, the ports, or the battery life gives an M4 owner a reason to upgrade.
If your M4 Air still does your work, keep it. This comparison is for a buyer choosing a machine to purchase, not for an owner looking for a reason to replace one that works.
The charger did move. The M4 ships with a 30W USB-C adapter on the 8-core GPU model, or a 35W Dual USB-C Port Compact adapter on the 10-core GPU model. The M5 ships with a 40W Dynamic Power Adapter rated to 60W max. It is a useful step up in the box. It is not a reason to buy one machine over the other.

External displays are the one hard line
The M4 supports up to two external displays at up to 6K at 60Hz, alongside its built-in display. For most desks, that is enough, and it stays enough.
The M5 raises the ceiling in a specific way. It supports two external displays at up to 6K at 60Hz or 4K at 144Hz, or a single external display at up to 8K at 60Hz, 5K at 120Hz, or 4K at 240Hz. If you run a high-refresh external monitor, the M5 is the only Air that drives it at full rate.
That is a hard requirement, not a preference: check your monitor’s resolution and refresh rate, and if it sits above the M4 ceiling, the decision is already made.


Size and memory, priced in the open
Take the sizes in price order. The 13-inch M5 starts at $1,299 with 16GB of memory, a 512GB SSD, and an 8-core GPU. The 15-inch M5 starts at $1,499 with 16GB of memory, a 512GB SSD, and a 10-core GPU, so the larger machine is not just a larger machine at the base tier: the extra $200 buys the 15.3-inch display, the two extra GPU cores, and a larger 66.5Wh battery.
Buy the 15-inch if the Air is your main screen and it lives on a desk. Buy the 13-inch if it lives in a bag.
Memory is the one decision neither generation lets you revisit. The M4 and the M5 both start at 16GB and offer 24GB and 32GB configurations, and neither can be upgraded after purchase. Sixteen gigabytes handles everyday work and light creative work well. Step to 24GB if you edit video, run virtual machines, or plan to keep the laptop for four or five years of heavier work.
Step to 32GB for heavy video work or virtualization as the main job. Storage can spill onto an external drive. Memory cannot spill anywhere.

Verdict
Buy the 13-inch MacBook Air with M5 at $1,299, with 16GB of memory and 512GB of storage, if you are buying an Air today. Buy the 15-inch M5 at $1,499 if you want the bigger screen and the base 10-core GPU. Buy the MacBook Air with M4 only at $799 or less, only in the 16GB configuration, and only if 256GB of storage genuinely covers your work for the life of the machine.
M4 owners should skip this generation and keep their money. Intel and M1 owners get the full gain in one step: the storage, the chip, the wireless, and the display support all move at once.
Price: From $1,099
Where to Buy: Apple MacBook Air M4 15-inch, 16GB / 256GB Midnight | Amazon