Aereo TV review

Aereo01

“I’m mad as hell, and I’m not going to take this anymore!”  Remember this quote from  the 1976 movie Network?  It sums up my feelings about the present state of pay-TV providers and forced me to do something about the ever increasing fees and poor customer service.  Thanks to Aereo, I’ve been able to dump the TV portion of my cable bill and now have a much better level of service and a reduced cost.  While this service may not be for everyone, it does merit a look, so let’s do it.So what is Aereo?  It’s a service that allows TV viewers to rent miniature TV antennas, at the Aereo offices, to capture local over the air (OTA) TV broadcasts, which are then streamed to the user via the Internet.  This programming can be displayed on a TV using a Roku (or through AirPlay using a supported iOS device and an Apple TV box) or viewed on a PC, iPad, or iPod. The rented antenna can be used for live viewing, or the program can be recorded at the Aereo facility for later streaming,  just like a DVR.  The Aereo service at present is only available in limited areas; New York City, Boston, Atlanta, Miami, Dallas, Houston, and Salt Lake City, but is on a fast expansion track.  Potential customers must live in the greater viewing area of those cities to receive the service.  I live in Southern New Hampshire, which is 70 miles from Boston, but is considered part of the Boston viewing area.

Before I get into the technical details, I’ll share how I decided to make the switch from the local monopoly’s TV offering to Aereo.

Ten years ago we moved into Southern NH  and signed up for something called extended basic cable TV service.  I think it cost us about $20/month.  After several years, the bill had more than doubled, so I discovered that there was something called limited basic service, which only had the local stations in the package.  This was fine by me because I wasn’t much of a TV watcher, and the locals kept us up to date on what was happening in the area.  The price was a reasonable $12-$14 per month, and the signal wasn’t encrypted, so I could plug the cable directly into the 3 TVs I had around the house.  It was even better when I finally subscribed to internet service from the cable company, because the limited basic was essentially free when packaged with the internet.  After a while, the price crept up to $24/month, but I didn’t complain, because now the limited basic was broadcast in HD using QAM.  Over time I replaced my analog TVs with flat screens that had QAM tuners, so life was good.

Then on July 23rd of this year the limited basic service was encrypted, after the FCC reversed itself on requiring that cable providers must keep local channels un-encrypted.   I was looking at a major price increase.  Yes, the cable company would supply up to 3 set-top boxes to decrypt the signal, and they would be free for a year or so.  Oh, but if I wanted the signal in HD, which I was getting before encryption, then I’d have to pay an additional $4.99/month for each of 3 boxes for 3 TVs.  Enough was enough, so I did something about it.  I cancelled the TV portion of my cable service and signed up for Aereo.  If I could, I would have put up an antenna, but because of my location, there is no reception either OTA or via satellite.

Aereo04

The only change I made to my viewing hardware, was an upgrade of my Roku player to the Roku 3.  I already had the Roku HD, but to ensure the best possible viewing experience for my spouse, I figured an upgrade was worth it.

Aereo05

If you’re not familiar with the Roku, it’s a device the allows streaming video from the internet to be displayed on a regular TV set.  It’s a very simple piece of hardware and consists of the box itself and a remote.

Aereo06

Because I would be streaming video over my local area network, I was concerned that streaming over WiFi might not be fast nor reliable enough.  The Roku 3 is the only device in their line that has an Ethernet port, making it a better choice for connection via my power-line network.  Also, the Roku 3 has an RF remote, so it’s not direction sensitive.

Aereo06.5

The main reason for getting Aereo was to replace the cable feeds for local channels.  Here’s what you see on the Roku after you subscribe.  The Aereo app is free, and there is a small authorizing step needed before you’re ready to go.

Aereo07

This is the main or home screen for the Roku app and the jump-off point for accessing the features of Aereo.  The search feature is rather powerful for searching both recorded content and future broadcasts from the guide.

Aereo08

The programming guide can be accessed by either time…

Aereo09

or channel.  This photo only shows part of the channels available.

Aereo10

When a program is selected, there are options to watch or record.  When you watch a program, it begins recording so that you can pause, rewind or fast forward.

Aereo11

If you’ve recorded programs previously, you can select them from the above screen.

There are other devices that support watching with Aereo, including an iPad app and a PC using a browser.

Aereo02

When using the PC and browser, the graphical interface is much different.  I find it  much easier to navigate, so if I want to record a program, I either do it using the PC or iPad.

Aereo03

Recorded programs display more completely in the browser.  They can then be played on the PC.

Aereo13

When displayed using the browser, the image can either be small or extended to full screen.

Aereo14

There is also a native iPad app with all the features and a much better GUI than the Roku app.  To take advantage of the features of the iPad app, you can enter two-screen mode when using the Roku, and control the stream with the iPad, but display the results on the TV.  The best of both worlds!

There are some adjustments that need to be made to your TV viewing habits when using Aereo.  Before I jumped in full-time ,I took advantage of their 30-day trial to test it out.  This made it much easier to sell the service to my spouse.  I’d suggest you do the same to minimize any hate and discontent from your significant other, especially if they’re technophobes. :)

If you’re a channel surfer or the type of person that turns the TV on in the morning and lets it run all day, you’re in for a different experience with Aereo.  That’s because Aereo is not channel centric, but program centric.  When you select a live program to watch, it will be streamed for the time shown in the guide and then stop at the end.  You will then need to select a different program to watch.  This action is analogous to watching recorded programs on a DVR.  Also, there’ll be many button pushes on the Roku remote before a program starts streaming.

The quality of the picture on my HD TV via the Roku is excellent, but things aren’t perfect.  Sometimes there is network congestion, and the stream buffers.  This can be lessened by adjusting the picture quality, but obviously it’s a trade-off.  I can live with the occasional buffering, and even when it gets excessive, I can have the live program recorded for later viewing.

After using Aereo for about a month, I upgraded from their $8/month plan to the $12/month plan.  Under the cheaper plan I would rent one antenna and have recording capacity of 20 hours and either record or watch one program.  Under the $12 plan I get 2 antennas and up to 60 hours of recording storage.  It also allows me to watch two programs or record two programs or watch one and record one program.  Neither of the plans require any long-term commitment.  They are month to month.

I’ve been extremely satisfied with the Aereo experience.  Their customer service is amazing.  Although communication is limited to email, when I experienced a problem, they responded in 4 hours and were able to fix the issue in 2 more.

My only concern is their survival.  The major networks haven’t taken too kindly to Aereo providing OTA signals to users over the Internet, because the networks generate a large amount of their revenue by selling these free signals to the cable providers.  So, rather than try to compete, the networks are trying to sue Aereo out of existence.  To date, Aereo has prevailed in several lawsuits, but the networks have decided to push the issue to the US Supreme Court rather than compete.

If you live in a serviced area, why not give Aereo a try?  They still have the 30 day free trial.

 

Product Information

Price:$8 per month or $12 per month
Manufacturer:Aereo
Requirements:
  • Broadband Internet
  • TV
  • Roku or Apple TV or PC or Mac or iPad
Pros:
  • Cost effective alternative to basic cable
  • Watch and record live TV
Cons:
  • None
Posted in: Audio, Video, TV Gear, Reviews

{ 19 comments… add one }

  • Tech October 24, 2013, 2:49 pm

    Thanks for posting this review!
    Aereo just came to Chicago, and sounds like a great addition to Hulu and netflix…as we have ditched cable and satellite.

  • Bill Kuch October 24, 2013, 3:13 pm

    Tech,

    You are welcome. Now that I have Aereo, I was able to discontinue Hulu Plus, which I used to watch TV shows. I can now record anything I can’t watch. I also used to have Netflix, but found out Redbox was a cheaper alternative for me. I don’t watch that many movies.

  • Xfader October 25, 2013, 8:38 am

    Aereo is great!Going to sign up today,I can’t wait!

  • brad October 25, 2013, 10:38 am

    Very interesting review and i will be certain to subscribe when it comes to the Kansas City market. Perhapsl I missed it but where does the Aereo antannae plug in? Thanks for the great review!!

  • Bill Kuch October 25, 2013, 10:59 am

    Brad,

    The Aereo antennas are at the Aereo facility in each geography where they provide service. The antenna is the size of a dime and they have thousands of them at their site. The signal from the antenna is then digitized and sent over the Internet to be played back on a subscribers device(s). I did mention this in the beginning of the review, ” It’s a service that allows TV viewers to rent miniature TV antennas, at the Aereo offices”, but I could have made it clearer. Thanks for reading. I’m still happy I signed up.

  • ron October 27, 2013, 2:27 pm

    Are NFL games live or are they blocked?

  • Bill Kuch October 27, 2013, 8:03 pm

    ron,

    Aereo receives the free over the air signal, using an antenna, from a designated geography, like Boston in my case and digitizes it to send over the Internet. So, if the game is broadcast over the air, then you will receive it via Aereo. They do not control the over the air signal.

  • Opp October 31, 2013, 1:49 am

    I cant wait until aereo arrives in Philadelphia.
    So far i use a combination of Hulu plus , amazon prime and Netflix

  • Nay November 11, 2013, 5:49 pm

    Do you need equipment (antenna/roku) for each television that you wish to use Aero on?

  • Bill Kuch November 11, 2013, 8:12 pm

    Nay,

    You will need a Roku at each TV on which you wish to use Aereo. The antennas are at the Aereo office. You can rent a maximum of 2, but they are shared between the display devices. So, you can only watch programs on 2 different TVs at a time. For me this is not a problem. If I move from one TV to another to view a show, I can select the program at the new TV and it informs me it is being watched on another set. I can then command Aereo to switch the output to the new TV.

  • Jane November 13, 2013, 9:18 pm

    Do I need a cable connection for the Roku box or will WiFi work? I currently pay $74 per month for cable and I don’t have HD!

  • Bill Kuch November 14, 2013, 6:23 am

    Jane,

    It works fine over WiFi. I have 2 Roku boxes that are WiFi only and have not experienced any problems. Every day I use Aereo, I like it more!

  • stacy November 23, 2013, 11:33 am

    Ok:-) I’m trying to understand this, you sayig roku 2 xd & the roku 3 with the aereo need no cable wifi? Because the roku & the aereo already have it? Plz jane or anyone let ne know Asap.

  • Bill Kuch November 23, 2013, 1:21 pm

    stacy,

    There seems to be some confusion, so let me use the analogy of Netflix. If you’re familiar with them, Aereo is similar and is just another app on the Roku box. Instead of streaming movies, Aereo streams live local channel television. If you already are using a Roku you need just download the Aereo app and subscribe to watch on your TV. Just to be perfectly clear, you will need broadband Internet service. This could be from the Cable Company or FIOS or DSL and remember you have to be in an area serviced by Aereo. I you don’t already have broadband, Aereo is probably not for you

  • steve December 20, 2013, 12:03 pm

    What are the basic requirements for membership? What does roku provide that the PC and TV combination doesn’t?

  • Bill Kuch December 20, 2013, 3:42 pm

    Steve,

    The monthly subscription is either $8 or $12 depending upon the number of antennas you rent. You could hook your PC to a TV, assuming you have the correct outputs and inputs, and display the Aereo stream. The Roku acts as a set top box and allows one to control the channels with a remote from the comfort of your sofa and you don’t tie up a PC in the process.

  • Jim January 3, 2014, 2:46 pm

    Aereo is a unique concept. I tried the 30 day service and decided it was not for me. Picture quality was the biggest reason. I didn’t have any buffering issues but there was a lot of pixilation in the picture quality. Any fast moving action scenes also show allot of pixilation. I have a ROKU 3 plugged directly into the router. My download speed is 57 MB. I also used my iPad and Apple TV. Still a poor picture. I was truly disappointed in the picture quality.

    My next attempt at getting a DVR solution for OTA will be to try a device called Simple TV. I’m hoping this solution produces a much better quality of picture,

  • NYC February 24, 2014, 4:13 pm

    When Time Warner went to battle with CBS last summer I dumped TW. Yes, I still have them for my internet. But, when Aereo came along I signed up. It’s terrific. I don’t watch that many shows and until or unless the Cable companies allow a la carte- which won’t happen, I refuse to pay the exboritant price of internet and 100 channels I don’t want or need. I don’t want a bundle.

    Yes, once in a while, there is some buffering and if it went on too long, I emailed AEREO.
    They respond faster than the EMT’s! And, gave me 1/2 month credit. There is HULU-basic which is fine. CRACKLE.COM has some terrific movies.

    And, now that Time Warner and Comcast have joined-if approved, the consumer will be the one who will be paying higher prices for even worse service.

    I hope AEREO prevails. Growing up, we had a TV with an antenna and received the shows we wanted to to watch. I can live without the premium channels.

    I just wish there was a way to completely cut the cord to the cable companies as they have been thieves for years.

  • Mak King March 10, 2014, 8:34 am

    I am doing the trial in NY area and think they need work on the quality. I get large blocky images (macro blocking) during fast scene transitions. The picture falls apart and recovers. And there is stuttering during slow panning left to right or zoom in shots.
    I tried this on PC and laptop and they don’t have an app for my Panasonic TV. I have tried their speed test and see these effects on Low MED or High. I only have 4 Mbps DSL but I watch HD, HDX on other services and do not have these issues. This is an issue with how Aereo is compressing the signal.
    They claim to be aware of the poor quality and are working on it. But there are really no scheduled date when they would improve the quality.
    I fear they will not be able to hold up with demand if they become popular. I could not watch the awards show because it was too popular. I could watch another show just fine but the show must have been streaming to too many. Aereo was aware and gave a credit on the account.

Leave a Comment