Yurtopia Yurbuds Review

Ears.  Everybody has them, and everybody’s are different.  So different, in fact, that it has been suggested that our ears might be suitable as a basis for biometric identification.  So if our ears are as unique as our fingerprints, why is it that our earbuds are not?  Yurtopia is a company that was started in an effort to address just that problem, and I was recently given the chance to try out their solution to the issue: Yurbuds.

I’ve always had a love-hate relationship with earbuds in general, but primarily with the way that they fit.  Apple’s earbuds and other one-size-fits-all earbuds fall out too easily.  Earbuds that come with multiple sized earpieces will stay in when fitted with the right earpiece, but they aren’t comfortable; they’re always just a little bigger than my ear canal, or they use a compression-and-expansion method to stay in place, and it’s only logical that your ear is going to start hurting eventually if something is trying to expand inside it.  The only remaining option, then, is custom earbuds.

Custom-fit earbuds aren’t exactly a new idea.  What they are, generally speaking, is expensive.  Etymotic offers a custom-fit option for their hf2 earbuds (if you live in the UK, that is), but it effectively doubles the price of the headset, which already retails for $180 in the US.  Yurbuds attempt to bring the benefits of custom-fit earbuds down to an affordable price point.

The first point worth noting here is that Yurbuds are not actually molded to fit your specific ear canals.  Rather, you send Yurtopia a photo of your ear with an item (a US quarter or an Apple earbud) as a size reference, and they analyze the photo using their FitScan technology.  This allows them to identify which of the half-dozen sizes of Yurbuds will best fit your ears.  If you have an iPhone, this process becomes even easier; the Size Yur Ear iPhone app automates this process, allowing you to take a picture of your ear with your iPhone and send it straight from the app.  Yurtopia informs me that, in the future, they plan on providing a version of the app that can perform the measurement directly within the app, without having to send a photo.

The Yurbuds themselves are simple caps of medical-grade silicone that fit over your earbuds.  They look somewhat alien compared to regular earbuds, because of their more organic shape.  Their appearance may be off-putting to some — they certainly don’t look as sleek and modern as most high-end earbuds, but then again, these are going in your ears, so who cares?  The package that I received from Yurtopia included a pair of Yurbuds pre-installed onto their Yurphones, which look and sound a lot like the standard Apple earbuds.  The fit, to be quite honest, is amazing.  Once I got past the initial weirdness of their appearance, I placed them into my ears, and they settled right into place.  The Yurbuds were comfortable enough that I was able to wear them for hours on end without the discomfort or pain that I’m used to from extended wear of normal earbuds, and they stay put well enough that I didn’t have to adjust or re-seat them even once during several hours of exercise and chores around the house.

Upon first sight, I was a little worried that the Yurbuds might prove deleterious to sound quality; they basically redirect the sound directly into the ear canal, and I was concerned that there might be some noticeable absorption of sound in specific ranges.  I’m pleased to report that my concerns were without merit, as I didn’t notice any degradation of sound with the Yurbuds installed on the Yurphones, as compared to the Yurphones alone.  In fact, the Yurbuds improved the transmission of sound, since they form a better seal than the standard Apple earbuds.  Not only that, but I found that the Yurbuds helped to isolate others from the sound of my music.  Sitting right next to me in a quiet room, my wife could not hear a single sound from my headphones, even as I listened at a very comfortable volume.

Sadly, I was not able to test the Yurbuds with the earbuds that I’ve been carrying for the past several years, a pair of Sony MDR-EX71s.  The Yurbuds simply did not fit on these earbuds correctly, something that I could have learned if I had contacted Yurtopia in advance.  Yurtopia welcomes questions about which earbud models are compatible with their Yurbuds, and provides a number to call if you have questions about headset compatibility.  As a general rule, however, it appears that Yurbuds basically work on anything that provides an earpiece roughly the size of the Apple earbuds.

It would be nice if Yurtopia would be a little more proactive about this, perhaps providing a list on their website of earbud models known to work with the Yurbuds.  They could even crowd-source this info, asking the Yurbuds-owning community to submit reports on which earbuds and Bluetooth headsets do or do not work with the Yurbuds.  Given that my MDR-EX71s are incompatible, I find myself wanting to buy a new pair that will work with the Yurbuds, and it would be nice to have a list of compatible models to shop from, rather than having to call a long-distance number to ask about each pair I’m considering before I purchase them.  It’s notable that there are scattered references to “Yuradapters” on the site, and a quick Google search turns up some YouTube videos detailing the installation of a small adapter that allows one to use Yurbuds with earbuds that would otherwise be incompatible.  Yuradapters do not appear to be available for sale on the Yurtopia site or elsewhere, however.

Yurbuds on my Jawbone Prime. The way it was meant to be.

That said, I did have one other audio device that I decided to try the Yurbuds on, and am I ever glad that I did.  It’s no secret that I really like Jawbone’s headsets, but the one thing about them with which I’ve never been 100% satisfied is how they fit in my ear.  They will fit and they will mostly stay, but they form a poor seal in my ear, and it becomes very hard to hear the person on the other end, especially in a noisy environment.  So I slipped one of the Yurbuds onto my Jawbone Prime (over the medium-size earpiece, mind you) and put it into my ear.

Let me say this for the record:  never before has putting something in my ear made me so happy.

The fit — as before — was perfect, but this was something else entirely.  The Jawbone stayed put in place without the aid of the ear loop, the voice sensor was firmly against my face, and I could hear every sound coming out of the headset with surprising clarity.  At this point, it did not matter to me how well the Yurbuds worked with stereo earbuds, because their performance on my Bluetooth headset alone was worth it.  I can say with absolute conviction that I plan to have Yurbuds on every Bluetooth headset I own from this day forward.

One more nice thing to note about the whole Yurbuds process is that, when you buy a pair, Yurtopia includes the size of Yurbuds on the invoice.  This makes it a simple matter to order additional pairs if you need them, without having to photograph your ear and re-submit it.

Yurbuds can be ordered by themselves for $19.99 (or with a pair of Yurphones for $29.99) directly from Yurtopia, or can also be found at a number of brick-and-mortar electronics and sporting goods retailers.  Retail packages include the two most common sizes of Yurbuds, as well as information on sizing your ear and obtaining a different size if neither of those fits.

In short, I have been quite pleasantly surprised by how much Yurbuds improve the earbud-wearing experience, and I have to say that a Jackson is a small price to pay to turn your favorite great-sounding but ill-fitting earbuds into the perfect pair of earbuds.

 

Product Information

Price:$20
Manufacturer:Yurtopia
Pros:
  • Comfortable, improved sound isolation, inexpensive, stays in place
Cons:
  • No maintained list of compatible earbud models
Posted in: Audio, Video, TV Gear, Reviews

{ 16 comments… add one }

  • Kara Shallenberg March 16, 2010, 12:58 pm

    Oooo neat-o! And very tempting. Great review, thanks.

  • Jared Morgan March 16, 2010, 8:10 pm

    I first read about yurbuds on the Gadgeteer about 3 months ago, where a short article about the product appeared in my google feeds.

    I contacted the company right away, and wanted to find out about the yurbuds and yuradapters. I sent about 5 emails to the company, but I heard nothing back. Just an out of office reply from one of the owners (I think it was anyhow).

    I got frustrated, because I have a pair of Sony MDR-EX90SL headphones, and wanted to get the yurphone silicone and yuradapters to see if the already excellent sound quality of these headphones would be enhanced.

    Like you say, there is no pricing information about the yuradapters on the site, which is frustrating. I also don’t have a quarter (because I live in Australia), or Apple headphones to use as a sizing tool.

    So if you’re reading this yurtopia, please think about your international customers. I know that if I got a set of yurbuds, half my office would also probably get them as well after seeing what they can do for standard bud earphones.

  • Andy Simmons March 16, 2010, 8:38 pm

    @Jared I’ve sent an email to my contact at Yurtopia to see if I can get any info on the Yuradapters.

    As for the measurement issue, it appears that an Australian 10-cent piece is smaller in diameter than a US quarter by less than one millimeter. If you cannot get your hands on a US quarter at your local bank, you may be able to substitute a 10-cent piece. There are only six possible sizes, and I can’t imagine that .8mm is going to make the difference.

  • Corinne March 16, 2010, 11:33 pm

    Now, this sounds like a great product.

    I’ve been through… probably 10 sets of headphones since New Years alone (no seriously), and one of my biggest problems is that the ear pieces just do not fit.

  • deanromero March 17, 2010, 1:36 am

    I wanted to provide an additional option. We make a very new, inexpensive product called Breppies. Breppies are made of a moisture resistant fabric, they make earbuds incredibly comfortable, and ensure you can be very active without your buds falling out. They also come in a wide variety of colors. It might be a great option for those of you with standard Apple or Apple type earbuds.

  • Dan at Yurbuds March 17, 2010, 6:26 pm

    @Jared,
    First of all, my sincerest apologies for the delay in getting back to you! Andy’s advice is great around the .10 piece. Please send your image and shipping address directly to me at photos@yurbuds.com and I am going to ship you a pair of yurbuds for free! Fyi, you can also get yurbuds in Australia at some Bay Audio Hearing Expert locations. I hope you (and your office) enjoy them!

    To all, we now have special pink yurbuds, called yurbuds4life! Every pair purchased includes a donation of $10 to help end breast cancer forever! You can check them out at http://www.yurbuds4life.org.

    Thanks again @gadgeteer!

    -Dan at Yurbuds

  • Jared Morgan March 17, 2010, 6:53 pm

    @Andy, thanks for the response. I’ll consider trying again. Perhaps if I just order a pair, I’ll get the information that I need. I’m really intrigued to try the yurbuds on some low grade headphones (such as the free ones you get when travelling on airlines) and see what difference it makes to the sound quality.

    I also recently got a Nokia phone which has pretty decent headphones. They are really uncomfortable to wear though; I think the yurbuds could really help with comfort.

  • Teresa May 13, 2010, 11:50 am

    I LOVE MY YURBUDS!!!!
    I have spent countless dollars and years trying to find earbuds that fit my ears, do not fall out, do not cause pain to my ears, and were still comfortable. While at the Disney Princess Half Marathon Expo in March I had told my running buddy I needed a good pair of earbuds. We found the Yurbud table and we all walked away with Yurbuds. I bought a pair for myself, a pair for my daughter and a pair for my sister-in-law. I am so happy to finally have a pair of earbuds that I LOVE:)

  • Chris R July 12, 2010, 10:34 pm

    I went into a slackers or a $2 wire and saw the demo for these, since it was a local STL business I thought I’d try them, I was so impressed I dropped $19.99 on these. All it took was a minute for them to measure me ear with a strange round ruler and I was off. These make any cheap headset feel better than Dr. Dres!

  • brad September 9, 2010, 7:39 pm

    I just got a pair of yurbuds. I think the price is a little too high for something I will almost definitely lose. They are cheap little pieces of rubber. They should send you a few sets for this much money considering what you actually get.

  • joan October 18, 2010, 9:45 am

    I bought a pair of these at the Expo, before the Portland Marathon last weekend. I am definitely in the minority – ’cause I gave them away soon after. Obviously I’m doing something wrong…but when I tried to “twist” the earbud to lock it in, it just fell out. After five or six tries, I gave up. Way too much effort and aggravation. Also twenty wasted dollars.

  • cdtan99 November 29, 2010, 12:28 pm

    I bought the Ironman series at the Javit Convention Center during the week of the NYC marathon. I was told that I’d get two pairs of yurbuds but the other pair didn’t fit. When I called customer service, I was told that only one pair will actually fit. What’s the use of having your ears measured if they’re gonna give you a pair that doesn’t fit anyway? Customer service said the same thing but until now their website still states that you get an extra pair of yurbuds for each purchase of the Ironman series. Don’t buy the Ironman series if you want two pairs.

  • Dan At Yurbuds December 8, 2010, 2:14 pm

    @Joan: I’m so sorry about the unability to use yurbuds. Some common problems people run in to are the rotation of the yurbud on the headphone. If you were sized at an expo, I am sure you were accurately sized, but if they were rotated the wrong way or on the wrong ear (L or R), it would make a difference. Please contact us at info@yurbuds.com if you would like to speak with customer service.

    @cdtan99: I’m sorry for any confusion at the NYC Marathon. The Ironman Series Yurbuds DO NOT come with two pairs of the same size. The extra $20 charge is not for the extra set of yurbuds, rather the upgraded headphones. The additional pair in the box is to fit the ears of a larger group of people who are buying our products at Big Box stores like Best Buy. PLEASE contact me at info@yurbuds.com and I will send you a FREE second set of Yurbuds to go with the ones you already purchased.

    Thanks!
    Dan@Yurbuds

  • joan December 8, 2010, 3:47 pm

    @Dan – OK, I take it all back. Imimpatient, old and cranky. Love the yurbuds and never run without them! I shouldn’t have left a review before I really gave them a chance. They stay in easily, and even work with a headband on (now that it’s cold.)

    They’re pink, too. Always a good thing.

  • joan December 8, 2010, 3:47 pm

    I’m so impatient that I can’t leave a legible comment, actually.

  • Brian November 21, 2011, 11:07 am

    I gotta say I’m a little disappointed in the response time for getting a sizing from emailing a picture to yurbuds. I’ve killed one side of two pairs of sony headphones including their “active” model from sweating during working out. I would like to try their offering but just under a weeks time isn’t a very encouraging turn around time.

Leave a Comment