HP iPAQ 910 Business Messenger Review

It’s been close to two years since I had a new HP iPAQ smartphone in my hands. The last one was the hw6945. Their latest device is the iPAQ 910. This QUAD band GSM phone has a nice collection of features including a QWERTY thumb keyboard, a camera, WiFi, Bluetooth, GPS, etc. But will this loaner unit be one that I will want to buy for myself? Let’s find out…

Hardware Specifications

Processor: Marvell PXA270 Processor, 416 MHz
Memory: 128 MB SDRAM main memory for running applications, 256 MB flash ROM
Operating system: Windows Mobile 6.1 Professional
Integrated wireless: Integrated Quad band GSM/GPRS/EDGE and Tri Band UMTS/HSDPA at up to 3.6/7.2 Mbps; Integrated WiFi – 802.11 b/g with WPA2 security; Integrated Bluetooth v2.0 with EDR; Integrated multi-mode GPS navigation with Google Maps
Display: 2.46-inch transmissive TFT 65,000 color 320 x 240 pixel touch panel display with LED backlight
Built-in camera: 3 Megapixel, autofocus, 4X digital zoom
Battery: 1940 mAh Lithium Ion rechargeable
Expansion: Micro SD card slot
Audio: Integrated microphone, receiver, speaker and mini-USB wired stereo headset
Dimensions: 114 x 64 x 15 mm (4. 5″ x 2.5″ x 0.6″)
Weight: 154g (5.4 oz)

HP iPAQ 910

Package Contents

iPAQ 910 smartphone
Standard battery
AC Adapter
USB synchronization cable
Stylus
Wired stereo headphones
Getting Started guide
HP iPAQ Companion CD

Hardware Design

The iPAQ has a shiny Black plastic front, with a chrome colored band that forms a U around the sides and top of the device. The sides are made of a smooth non-shiny Black plastic, while the back of the phone has a thin rubber-like coating.

HP iPAQ 910
HP iPAQ 910

Above the display is a LED that is used for battery level / charging status and notifications. Turning the phone over, you’ll notice the 3MP camera lens, flash, self-portrait mirror, speaker and stylus.

HP iPAQ 910

On the Left side, you will find the volume up/down button and voice commander / notes application launch button. Below those two buttons is the MicroSD slot and a mini USB connector, both of which are covered by a protective rubber flap. The buttons on both sides of the device are flat and somewhat difficult to locate just by feel.

HP iPAQ 910

On the opposite side, there is a scroll wheel, OK button and the camera application launch button.

HP iPAQ 910

The power button is located on the top edge of the phone, along with a reset switch and a GPS external antenna port. I like that HP included the reset switch. Most devices these days require you to remove the battery to do a soft reset.

HP iPAQ 910

The navigation key layout and QWERTY keyboard are roomy and comfortable to use. The domed center select button is easy to locate with your thumb. Around it is a plastic ring that can be pressed up/down, Left and Right. There are the normal Green and Red call send and end buttons, along with buttons for the Left and Right menu soft keys. There is also a button to launch the calendar, start menu, email and OK. The thumb keyboard keys are dome shaped and easy to press. All of the keys have good tactile feedback and are backlit, making them easy to see in dim environments. I didn’t have any issues or complaints using the keyboard for normal text input and text messaging.

HP iPAQ 910

The display is one of the nicer ones I’ve seen in awhile. Although it is small, it is crisp, bright and easy to read – indoors. Outside in full sunlight, it’s pretty much impossible to read unless you have the brightness cranked to the maximum setting and you use your hand to shield the sun from the screen. For touchscreen use, I found the screen to be responsive to stylus input and finger presses.

Size and Feel

I prefer phones that have a readily accessible keyboard. Phones like the Palm Treo and Centro are ones that I usually gravitate towards because I find it easier to press a physical button, than a touch screen to make calls and do other tasks. I’ve been using a Centro for several months now and before that, it was the Treo 680. Device size is important to me because I don’t wear a belt case or anything like that. I usually just slip my phone in my back pocket or even just carry it around in my hand when I go from location to location during my day job.

HP iPAQ 910

Here’s how the 910 (Center) compares to the Treo 680 (on the Left) and the Centro (on the Right) width-wise.

HP iPAQ 910

Although the iPAQ is wider than those two smartphones, it’s the thinnest of the three (it’s on the bottom of the stack in the image above).

HP iPAQ 910

This phone feels smaller in hand than the Treo 680 due to the thinness. But the width is definitely noticeable when compared to the Centro, which easily slips into most of my pants pockets. The iPAQ isn’t as portable (for me) in that regard.

As far as sturdiness, the iPAQ feels solid in hand. It doesn’t creak or crack when you squeeze the sides and has only a very slight button rattle when you shake it.

Camera

The 910 has a built in 3MP camera with a flash. Here are some sample images that I snapped using the maximum resolution of 2048 x 1536:







Click thumbnail to see full size image

As you can see, the images aren’t the best. They are a little fuzzy and one of the indoor shots has a slight green cast to it. I wouldn’t want to rely on the camera to be my only means of snapping pictures, but in a pinch, it does ok.

Performance as a PDA, WiFi web browser and a Phone

I didn’t have any problems using the iPAQ as a PDA. System performance is snappy and applications launched quickly. I even watched a few movies and videos and was happy using this smartphone as a media player. Of course the screen is very small, but video was smooth and easy to view.

Using the built in WiFi to surf web pages with Pocket Internet Explorer is quick and easy. Google maps works very well via WiFi too.

As far as using the iPAQ as a phone, I didn’t have any issues with dropped calls or signal strength with AT&T. The 910 is an unlocked GSM phone with 3G capability, but I couldn’t test 3G as it’s not yet rolled out in my area. The only issue that I noticed right away was that the volume level was too low in the earphone. Using it as a speakerphone wasn’t a problem for me, but when I wanted to talk normally using the built-in earphone, I found myself straining to hear the other person – even when I had the volume set to the max.

Battery

The HP iPAQ 910 has a high capacity 1940mAh Lithium Ion battery, which sounds great as most phones do not have batteries that large. That said, I didn’t find that the 910 lasted any longer per charge than other smartphones. I didn’t do any special battery drain tests, but with normal use (a few calls, some PIM access, a few email checks per day, ebook reading here and there), I was only able to get about 2 days per charge.

Software

In addition to the regular Windows Mobile 6.1 Professional software bundle, you also get a few other goodies that include:

HP PrintSmart – Print via Bluetooth and WiFi to HP printers
Sun’s Java VM – Run Java apps on your iPAQ
Voice Commander – Allows you to control your smartphone with your own voice commands. Doesn’t require special training
Remote Desktop Mobile – VNC client
Internet Connection Sharing – Phone tethering application
HP iPAQ GPS Position Accelerator – Downloads satellite data for faster GPS access. Still need a 3rd party GPS mapping and navigation software to take advantage of the built in GPS feature

Conclusion

I’ve used the HP iPAQ 910 for a week or so now and have compiled the following list of likes and dislikes…

Likes:
QWERTY keyboard – I like the feel of the domed keys
5-way nav button – Doesn’t feel cheesy like some nav buttons
Scroll wheel – I like the location on the Right side of device
Display – Bright and crisp
MicroSD – Easy access and SDHC compatible
Stylus – Telescoping, but sturdy and thicker than most

Dislikes:
Low call volume
No GPS included mapping / navigation software
No built in InfraRed port
Width of phone
Fuzzy camera snapshots

When it comes down to it, I like this device as a PDA, but as a phone, the low call volume is what really kills it for me. I don’t usually use a Bluetooth headset, so if I have to strain to hear someone talking even in a relatively quiet area, that’s going to be a real problem for me. For that reason, I won’t be using purchasing an HP iPAQ 910 for myself. Let’s hope that HP comes out with a successor to the 910 that is a bit smaller physically and better volume. If they do, I’ll be very interested in trying it out as I’ve always liked HP iPAQ devices.

 

Product Information

Price:499.99
Manufacturer:Hewlett Packard
Pros:
  • Snappy performance
  • Bright, crisp display
  • QWERTY keyboard
Cons:
  • Low call volume
  • Mapping / navigation software not included
  • Fuzzy camera snapshots
Posted in: Windows Phone, Wireless

{ 11 comments… add one }

  • Jake Tongue September 22, 2008, 9:32 am

    woo-hoo the gadgeteer is back. Also julie when do you think we’ll see the 4th gen nano review

    1
  • Julie September 22, 2008, 9:40 am

    Jake:

    Back? I didn’t know that I was gone???

    Just received my Orange 4G Nano the other day. Review soon :o)

    2
  • Mark Ryan September 22, 2008, 9:47 am

    I too am an HP6945 fan and it did include the navigation software. I suppose I can move the software from my 6945 over to the 910 but I am concerned about the volume. Did you contact HP about he volume problem? I wonder if it is a fluke as the 6945 volume is fine.

    Bottom line, would you prefer a new 6945 or a new 910?

    3
  • Julie September 22, 2008, 10:05 am

    Mark:

    I didn’t contact HP about the volume issue, but after I completed my review, I did some reading of other people’s reviews and reviews on HP’s own site and noticed a least a few others mentioned the same issue.

    I would rather have the 910 over the 6945. :o)

    4
  • jester02k September 25, 2008, 10:54 pm

    Hey Julie
    Glad to hear it wasn’t just me with the call volume a buddy of mine has one of these and I wanted to check it out I was thinking on buying one used it to make a call I swear I could barely hear the other party. Plus the screen size it was way too small for any real use to me. I ended up with a T-Mobile Dash
    and an IPAQ 211 for the PDA I guess I’m old school that plus a 16g SD don’t hurt

    5
  • Dick September 27, 2008, 9:16 am

    Julie.

    Do you use the Palm Desktop with your Centro?

    I use the Desktop with my Palm Tungsten E on a Windows 2k computer that I am in the process of discarding. I want to use the desktop with my new Centro and the E, but, it will not Sync on a 64-bit OS on my new computer with Widows Vista Ultimate 64-bit (nor will it in the forseeable future as Palm does not seem to be working on a 64-bit driver). Do you know of a workaround?

    Dick

    [Edited at September 28, 2008 12:20:36 PM.]

    6
  • Julie September 27, 2008, 9:44 am

    Dick:

    No, I don’t use the Palm Desktop with my Centro. I’m a Mac person. I use Missing Sync :o)

    7
  • Dick September 28, 2008, 2:42 pm

    Julie.

    Thanks for the rapid reply. I was afraid there might not be another sync work around which I am assuming Missing Sync must be for the Mac.

    Dick

    8
  • Julie September 28, 2008, 3:28 pm

    Dick:

    Yes, Missing Sync is for the Mac. I don’t know of a 64bit solution for Palm syncing. Sorry.

    9
  • Rick November 2, 2009, 12:36 am

    Dear Julie:

    Can you sync the ipaq 910 with a Mac OS X?

    10
  • Julie November 2, 2009, 8:54 am

    @Rick Take a look at PocketMac ( http://www.pocketmac.com ) or Missing Sync ( http://markspace.com/ ).

    11

Leave a Comment