Comments on: Playaway Audio Book http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/ Gadget reviews and news by Julie Strietelmeier and friends since 1997 Sun, 08 Nov 2009 06:27:19 -0500 http://wordpress.org/?v=abc hourly 1 By: betatrom http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/comment-page-1/#comment-23170 betatrom Tue, 28 Aug 2007 04:31:13 +0000 #comment-23170 I’d like to post a review of <strong><a href="http://www.booksshouldbefree.com">BooksShouldBeFree.com</a></strong>, a site I found that is very well laid out. It has only around 100 eBooks but they are the 100 most popular books in the public domain. Also, the site has photos of every book so you can be sure of what you're downloading. As the website's name suggests (<strong><a href="http://www.booksshouldbefree.com">BooksShouldBeFree.com</a></strong>), all mp3 audio book downloads are free. I’d like to post a review of BooksShouldBeFree.com, a site I found that is very well laid out. It has only around 100 eBooks but they are the 100 most popular books in the public domain. Also, the site has photos of every book so you can be sure of what you’re downloading. As the website’s name suggests (BooksShouldBeFree.com), all mp3 audio book downloads are free.

]]> By: woofb http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/comment-page-1/#comment-23169 woofb Tue, 14 Nov 2006 09:00:26 +0000 #comment-23169 I hadn't actually considered the question of a particular market in Special Needs, but you're quite right that it would serve that quite well. In the UK there seems to be a Read and Write initiative by the government or somebody which has brought out a lot of very short (novella-length) books in a package with the written text and audio tape and CD, so there obviously is a use for that concept. A school with a number of slow readers could do worse than get a bunch of Playaway titles, because they would indeed benefit from the independence from technology and the fact that it's a locked-content device. My issue with the Playaway is that it's aimed heavily at the mass market, with a selection of bestseller titles most people probably won't want to read more than once, and I doubt it'll take off. Locked content works seriously well for small-market applications where an institution buys a package of items with content loaded--modern museum audio tour guides are probably likely to work this way, so that the public isn't likely to nick the thing and it's kept simple. For the mass market, consumers or public libraries, there would be more to lose if the format didn't take off. I can see benefits for public libraries in using the Playaway format: part of the title can't be lost as with tapes and CDs, and it would discourage theft, but I think the large initial outlay and doubt over the format's likely success would put them off. There's also the risk of the library user losing the damn thing--cost of replacement would be high, and if the company goes under they're stuck... For specific purposes, like the school with slow learners or companies doing training audio stuff, the Playaway concept would work a lot better. If they did classic texts where there might be a steady slow-trickle demand from students, that might also work. I feel they're going to come up against the inertia and diversity of the mass market, though. I hadn’t actually considered the question of a particular market in Special Needs, but you’re quite right that it would serve that quite well. In the UK there seems to be a Read and Write initiative by the government or somebody which has brought out a lot of very short (novella-length) books in a package with the written text and audio tape and CD, so there obviously is a use for that concept. A school with a number of slow readers could do worse than get a bunch of Playaway titles, because they would indeed benefit from the independence from technology and the fact that it’s a locked-content device.

My issue with the Playaway is that it’s aimed heavily at the mass market, with a selection of bestseller titles most people probably won’t want to read more than once, and I doubt it’ll take off.

Locked content works seriously well for small-market applications where an institution buys a package of items with content loaded–modern museum audio tour guides are probably likely to work this way, so that the public isn’t likely to nick the thing and it’s kept simple.

For the mass market, consumers or public libraries, there would be more to lose if the format didn’t take off. I can see benefits for public libraries in using the Playaway format: part of the title can’t be lost as with tapes and CDs, and it would discourage theft, but I think the large initial outlay and doubt over the format’s likely success would put them off. There’s also the risk of the library user losing the damn thing–cost of replacement would be high, and if the company goes under they’re stuck…

For specific purposes, like the school with slow learners or companies doing training audio stuff, the Playaway concept would work a lot better. If they did classic texts where there might be a steady slow-trickle demand from students, that might also work. I feel they’re going to come up against the inertia and diversity of the mass market, though.

]]> By: JLawrence http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/comment-page-1/#comment-23168 JLawrence Tue, 07 Nov 2006 18:11:26 +0000 #comment-23168 I am a school library media specialist and I disagree. I think that this could be an extremely valuable tool, especially for assistive technology in schools and school libraries. When addressing differential learning it is important to take into consideration that some students just have trouble comprehending written information. Having an all-in-one packaged audio book would allow them to listen to the words while following along in a book, a great teaching method, especially since even though it seems like everyone has a computer and an mp3 player, this is simply not true. Having an all-in-one package allows students who may not have working equipment at home to still take advantage of audio books. The playaway also has a slow play option which is key for this kind of use. I am a school library media specialist and I disagree. I think that this could be an extremely valuable tool, especially for assistive technology in schools and school libraries. When addressing differential learning it is important to take into consideration that some students just have trouble comprehending written information. Having an all-in-one packaged audio book would allow them to listen to the words while following along in a book, a great teaching method, especially since even though it seems like everyone has a computer and an mp3 player, this is simply not true. Having an all-in-one package allows students who may not have working equipment at home to still take advantage of audio books. The playaway also has a slow play option which is key for this kind of use.

]]> By: solomail http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/comment-page-1/#comment-23167 solomail Sat, 04 Nov 2006 23:03:14 +0000 #comment-23167 An Audible book on a Shuffle beats this for my own use. Plus the Audible format is re-downloadable. I can see it as a novelty gift for up to $20. I think libraries can make better use of their funds. Still it's fun to see the gadget world at work! An Audible book on a Shuffle beats this for my own use. Plus the Audible format is re-downloadable.

I can see it as a novelty gift for up to $20. I think libraries can make better use of their funds. Still it’s fun to see the gadget world at work!

]]> By: visitken http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/comment-page-1/#comment-23166 visitken Fri, 03 Nov 2006 17:58:08 +0000 #comment-23166 Although I agree with woofb that Playaway won't succeed, I'm still rooting for them the same way I supported Palm all these years even though I knew the non-smartphone PDA was old technology. I have a difficult time believing that hardcover buyers will fork over $50 for a book-on-a-chip. Playaway's audience is mostly current audio book listeners, not hardcover book fans. I have a half dozen e-books loaded on my Tungsten C right now (as well as one Audible title) and none cost me more than $15. I can't actually recall the last time I spent more than $20 on a book that wasn't a university class text... Although I agree with woofb that Playaway won’t succeed, I’m still rooting for them the same way I supported Palm all these years even though I knew the non-smartphone PDA was old technology. I have a difficult time believing that hardcover buyers will fork over $50 for a book-on-a-chip. Playaway’s audience is mostly current audio book listeners, not hardcover book fans. I have a half dozen e-books loaded on my Tungsten C right now (as well as one Audible title) and none cost me more than $15. I can’t actually recall the last time I spent more than $20 on a book that wasn’t a university class text…

]]> By: isobutane http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/comment-page-1/#comment-23165 isobutane Fri, 03 Nov 2006 09:47:12 +0000 #comment-23165 As a long-time subscriber to Audible, I was interested in this new audiobook format, and I can see the point even if you already have a small portable device. I run my audiobooks off my Treo (I can use AudibleAir to download books on the go) and my Nano...both substantially smaller than the new format, and the titles are less expensive through Audible. I can see this as a good way to go if you are on the road somewhere and need to get an audiobook and don't have access to a computer to download Audible content. Books on tape still cost a fortune, and ebooks for PDA's now cost more than their bookstore analogue...but digital audiobooks are less expensive than their physical bretheren. It's an interesting idea, and if it catches on, might be a decent replacement for the audiobook download while on the road. Thanks for the review! As a long-time subscriber to Audible, I was interested in this new audiobook format, and I can see the point even if you already have a small portable device. I run my audiobooks off my Treo (I can use AudibleAir to download books on the go) and my Nano…both substantially smaller than the new format, and the titles are less expensive through Audible. I can see this as a good way to go if you are on the road somewhere and need to get an audiobook and don’t have access to a computer to download Audible content. Books on tape still cost a fortune, and ebooks for PDA’s now cost more than their bookstore analogue…but digital audiobooks are less expensive than their physical bretheren. It’s an interesting idea, and if it catches on, might be a decent replacement for the audiobook download while on the road. Thanks for the review!

]]> By: woofb http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/comment-page-1/#comment-23164 woofb Fri, 03 Nov 2006 09:44:50 +0000 #comment-23164 It's a solution to a problem that's already dying away. I have no doubt it's probably well-implemented, but it won't catch on. It would be an excellent thing for old people who want an alternative to tape that's very simple, but because you're not only locked into a format but locked into a *title*, it won't work. Almost anybody younger or less afraid of technology will see this as a backward step, because swapping Playaway titles (on ebay, with friends, at the library) depends on the product being extremely successful, and there's nothing to suggest it will be. I'd actually consider this for classic audiobooks that I'd listen to a number of times, but it has one big, big flaw the way they're doing it with popular bestsellers: to be any use at all, there need to be quite a lot of titles easily available. It's a small American company, not Sony or iTunes, so it'll probably have a few sales over a couple of years and then sink without trace, leaving behind a hardcore of devoted listeners who swap titles over the Internet. It's useless for libraries because it's too big a risk of exactly this 'the-format-won't-take-off' variety. Most public libraries are still doing audiobooks on tape/cd, with a small number doing modern digital formats with DRM. They know how to shelve tapes and CDs, there is shelving of the right size, and there is a huge selection of titles in a format which won't disappear without trace in a year or two. In order to make the Playaway work for libraries, the market would have to take it up in a big way so they wouldn't be investing in numbers of titles in an unsuccessful format (only available from one company), and I can't see any way this would happen. It’s a solution to a problem that’s already dying away. I have no doubt it’s probably well-implemented, but it won’t catch on. It would be an excellent thing for old people who want an alternative to tape that’s very simple, but because you’re not only locked into a format but locked into a *title*, it won’t work. Almost anybody younger or less afraid of technology will see this as a backward step, because swapping Playaway titles (on ebay, with friends, at the library) depends on the product being extremely successful, and there’s nothing to suggest it will be.

I’d actually consider this for classic audiobooks that I’d listen to a number of times, but it has one big, big flaw the way they’re doing it with popular bestsellers: to be any use at all, there need to be quite a lot of titles easily available. It’s a small American company, not Sony or iTunes, so it’ll probably have a few sales over a couple of years and then sink without trace, leaving behind a hardcore of devoted listeners who swap titles over the Internet.

It’s useless for libraries because it’s too big a risk of exactly this ‘the-format-won’t-take-off’ variety. Most public libraries are still doing audiobooks on tape/cd, with a small number doing modern digital formats with DRM. They know how to shelve tapes and CDs, there is shelving of the right size, and there is a huge selection of titles in a format which won’t disappear without trace in a year or two. In order to make the Playaway work for libraries, the market would have to take it up in a big way so they wouldn’t be investing in numbers of titles in an unsuccessful format (only available from one company), and I can’t see any way this would happen.

]]> By: Julie http://the-gadgeteer.com/2006/11/02/playaway_audio_book/comment-page-1/#comment-23163 Julie Fri, 03 Nov 2006 02:06:22 +0000 #comment-23163 Post your comments on the Playaway Audio Book review. <a href="http://www.the-gadgeteer.com/review/playaway_audio_book">http://www.the-gadgeteer.com/review/playaway_audio_book</a> Just click the POST REPLY button on this page. Post your comments on the Playaway Audio Book review.

http://www.the-gadgeteer.com/review/playaway_audio_book

Just click the POST REPLY button on this page.

]]>