I.R.I.S. IRISPen Express Text Recognition Pen Scanner

There have been so many times that I have needed to transpose written text from
a document in hand to a document on my computer. When it is an entire document,
such as a lease on which I am changing terms before returning, I’ll generally
scan the entire document into Word using my desktop scanner/printer combo and
edit from within the document itself. But when it is only a couple of sentences
or a few random phrases which need to be transferred from hard copy to my
desktop, I will generally just enter them via keyboard because it is a pain to
scan an entire document to extract what might amount to just a few lines worth of text.
I am not exactly a touch typist – six fingers are more my speed – so anything
that will make my time at the keyboard easier is a welcome addition to the
gadget bin.

When I was offered the chance to review the
IRISPen
Express Text Recognition Pen Scanner
, I thought it might be interesting to
see if using such a device would be that much more convenient than just biting
the bullet and entering the text myself. According to the manual which
accompanied the IRISPen, when the pen is slid over a line of text, the text "is
entered into your application instantly, as if keyed in but up to 30 times
faster. Up to a 100 characters can be entered per second. Cut from paper, paste
to Windows: can you imagine a simpler way of entering text?"

And that quote? Yah…I scanned it directly from the manual into the
FrontPage document I am using to write this review. However, what you see above
was edited a bit from what was actually copied. How much did I have to
edit to get the final result? We’ll get into that further into the review. For
now, let’s take a look at the IRISPen itself.

The IRISPen Express is one of four different versions offered by I.R.I.S.,
and it is designated as the version for home users.
Also
available are versions
for executives, Asian executives and those involved
in banking or similar industries. The

specific features of each version are slightly different
, therefore in this
review I will be focusing solely on the Express and its capabilities.

Included in the box are the IRISPen with its USB tether cable, the CD with
necessary desktop software, PC & Mac quick start guides and a user manual.

The IRISPen measures approximately 5" long x 1.5" wide x 1" thick and weighs
3.1 ounces including its cable. The head of the "pen" includes a roller which
operates as a "start switch", which turns on when rolled across paper, and turn
off when it is lifted. Above the roller ( to its left in this picture) is the
scanner view window, which emits a green beam when the scanner is activated. The
ridge in the middle of the scanner window is the line guide, and
according to the manual, "the IRISPen recognizes the text line closest to the
line guide." Yes, I scanned that, too – no editing necessary.

The button on the side of the IRISPen is user programmable, which means it
can be set to perform one of  eleven functions with a single click, and a
second with a double click. I have mine set to the default functions, which are
<Enter> with a single click and <Tab> with a double.

The forward button on the pen is also user programmable, and once again I
have left it at the default settings, which are <Space> with one click and
<Cursor Left> with a double click. The sliding button to the rear is a
mystery – I could not find any reference to it in the manual and it did not
appear to do anything to the input or output that I could discern. Since all of
the manual’s pictures of the pen in use show it positioned toward the rear of
the pen, that is where I kept it while doing actual testing.

 

This is the software screen from which the buttons are assigned:

The back side of the IRISPen has no buttons or features – just a hole in
which a structural screw has been placed. There are almost seven feet of USB cable
running from the rear of the scanning pen, so there should be enough even if the
computer’s USB ports are located under the user’s desk. For convenience, the IRISPen will work
properly from a hub.

The IRISPen is fatter than a typical pen, but overall it fit in my hand quite
comfortably.

Setup is accomplished by installing the accompanying CD, which must be done before plugging the IRISPen into the USB port.
During install, the following window will pop up…

…just hit Continue Anyway and install the software. At this time, the
IRISPen may be plugged into an empty USB port, and the Hardware Wizard will run.
Leaving the CD in the bin, hit "Next".

Once the Hardware Wizard has run, everything will be set up and ready to go. The following icon is
installed on the desktop…

…which when pressed causes the following window to appear.

Calibration simply involves pressing the IRISPen to a blank piece of white
paper and pressing it down. An incremental bar will show as progress occurs, and
once 100% is reached, the device is calibrated and ready to operate.

When the IRISPen program is on, a moveable toolbar will appear on the PC’s
screen which displays the current mode of the pen. Double-clicking on the menu
will pull up the scanner’s menu.

In order to use the IRISPen properly, you must practice! After
calibration, a scan test should be performed in which the user runs the pen over
the words in a steady rate. I kept the line I was scanning lined up with the
line guide and the IRISPen was set to Alphanumeric and English.

According to my test scan, I seem to have the hang of this. Now it’s time to
try entering text into my document. To use, the IRISPen must be held like a
pencil, but almost vertically. According to the Quick Start Guide, it is best to
"hold the pen almost vertically. of less than 5 for scanning."
Hmmm…that didn’t scan very well. It should have said, "hold the pen almost
vertically. angle of less than 5 preferred for and scanning." Nope…that’s not
it, either.

In case you didn’t catch it, I was trying to scan the wording under the
exclamation point in the picture above. One last try – "hold the pen almost
vertically. angle of less than 5 is preferred for .nd scanning."

All right…I don’t think the IRISPen likes red ink so much. Anyway!

The scanning alignment is set on this screen, which allows the choice of
where scanning will or won’t stop on a particular line of text.

Since I am scanning directly into this review, I selected Application – mode
1. Clipboard is for scanning items which need to be saved – such as small images
or signature files.

…which removes scanned text from the clipboard…

…and allows it to be saved as a bitmap file, like this.

However, for typing directly into a document like I am doing for this review,
the Output Target "Application – mode 1" should be selected. Using just the
slightest angle from a complete vertical, I scanned items from the included
practice sheet in as straight a row as possible in a slow and steady swipe.

1. What I am scanning: Big bold letters at the top of a page.

What I got

Learn how to write again with your 

Second Try:

T Jearn how to write a~ain with vour IRISPen!

Third Try:

Learn now to Wrlle agalll Willi yuur .lKl~ren!

Fourth Try:

Learn hOW to write agaIn with your IRISPen!

Fifth Try:

Learn how to write again with your IRISPen!

Conclusion: Multiple tries, but I eventually got it.

2. What I am scanning: This will be a little bit trickier, as this
sentence is parsed like a short paragraph which will take several scans to
correctly enter. In order to show each line as it was originally printed, I will
start each scan on a new line. However, had I wanted to, the scans would have
followed each other on the same line.

What I got:

fhe IRISPen is a unique hand-held OCR developed by I.R.I.S.; to date, it is
both the USB based and the only greyscale pen

Conclusion: Not bad! Only the first letter was messed up – which
should be simple to correct. I decided to set the pen to accept "All characters"
in output menu, hoping that would correct the problem.

3. What I am scanning: A Bold heading with italics following.

What I got:

Typefaces

rhe IRISPen being an omnifont recognition system, you

an read virtually any font. Here are some examples:

Conclusion: Even with the IRISPen set to scan "All characters", it
still seems to be dropping or mangling the first letters in a series. It is also
dropping the letter formatting, but that was to be expected. I was impressed
that it was able to read the formatted letters, though.

4. What I am scanning: Another paragraph style sentence which will
require multiple passes to enter. However, there is another sentence above it
which may also be picked up by the scanner.

What I got:

But which typefaces, typestyles, type sizes and

pedal characters can the IRISPen read?

Second Try:

ut which typefaces, typestyles, type sizes and

special characters can the IRISPen read?

Third Try:

ut which typefaces, typestyles, type sizes and

specIal characters can the IRISPen read?

Fourth Try:

But which typefaces, typestyles, type sizes and

special characters can the IRISPen read?

Conclusion: Still dropping first letters at times, and it sometimes
takes multiple passes to get a sentence to appear correctly.

5. What I am scanning: A tricky paragraph style which will require
multiple passes as well as correct reading of special symbols and punctuation.

What I got:

Die deutsche Sprache hat Symbole wie 0, a, B und A.  (<– picking up
words from the line above the one I am trying to scan!)

lut let’s not forget that the IRISPen I (<–correct line now…)

lso recognizes reading marks (- ; : ‘ " 

and "special" symbols such as *, &,

, +, -, #, $, £ and ¥.

Second Try:

llso recogni zes reading marks (- ; : ‘ " (<– read the wrong line)

But let’s not forget that the IRISPen

also recognizes reading marks (- ; : I"    ;

ilso recogni zes reading marks (- ; ~ I 11 (<– read the wrong line)

l) and "special" symbols such as * I &,    

§, +, -, #, $, £ and ¥.

Third Try:

But let’s not forget that the IRISPen    "

But let’s not forget that the IRISPen    . But let’s not
forget that the IRISPen ) !) and "special" symbols such as  (<–I could not
get it to pick up the correct second line)

? !) and "special" symbols such as *, &,

§, +, -, #, $, £ and ¥.

Fourth Try:

Butt let’s not forget that the IRISPen   

Iso recognizes reading marks (- . . , "

? !) and "special" symbols such as *, &,    I

;, +, -, #, $, £ and ¥.

Fifth Try:

It let’s not forget that the IRISPen   

ttlso recogni zes reading marks (_ . . ‘"    I

? !) and "special" symbols such as *, &,    _’"

, +, -, #, $, £ and ¥.

Conclusion: Feh. Multiple tries and some were better than others – but
none were exactly right and it took a lot longer to do than I would have liked.
Honestly, it got to be pretty frustrating.

6. What I am scanning: The IRISPen is programmed to be able to
recognize up to 55 languages, including Afrikaans, Albanian, American English,
Basque, Brazilian, Breton, British English, Bulgarian, Byelorussian, Catalan,
Corsican, Croatian, Czech, Danish, Dutch, Estonian, Finnish, French, Frisian,
Galician, German, Greek, Hungarian, Icelandic, Indonesian, Irish (Gaelic),
Italian, Lithuanian, Luxemburgh, Macedonian, Malay, Mexican, Norwegian, Nynorsk,
Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Russian, Scottish (Gaelic), Serbian, Slovak,
Slovenian, Spanish, Swahili, Swedish, Tagalog, Turkish, Ukrainian, Bulgarian –
English, Byelorussian – English, Greek – English, Macedonian – English, Russian
– English, Serbian – English, Ukrainian – English, Numeric. This time I decided
to change the language to French, and see how I did scanning the exotic letters.

What I got:

Les français aiment le é, à, î et E.

Conclusion: Why did I have better luck scanning French than I did
English? Near flawless

 

So what do I think of the IRISPen, will it be my new text entry system when I
am trying to move small chunks of written text to my computer? Probably not. The
reason being that for what this gadget cost, for the amount of times I had to
rescan items to get them to show up correctly, and for the amount of aggravation
caused when I thought I had done a flawless scan only to have gibberish
returned…I probably would do better just to continue manually typing when I
have small amounts of information to transpose.

IRISPen manuals may be downloaded
here.

 

Product Information

Price:149.99
Manufacturer:I.R.I.S.
Requirements:
  • For Windows: A Pentium 166 MHz with 16 MB RAM and 30 MB free disk space is recommended Runs on Windows XP, ME, 2000 or 98
  • For Mac OS: A Mac OS computer with a G3 processor. Supports Mac OS X up to 10.4 and Mac OS 9.x
  • Disk space: 50 MB
  • A free USB port or from a powered USB hub
  • A CD-ROM drive
Pros:
  • With practice, most text can be accurately scanned directly to documents
Cons:
  • Expensive
  • Results vary, multiple passes may be necessary
  • If on is in a hurry, manual text entry may be preferable
Posted in: Computer Gear, Gear, Laptops and Gear, Miscellaneous

{ 22 comments… add one }

  • Judie November 22, 2005, 3:50 pm

    Post your comments here on the I.R.I.S. IRISPen Express Text Recognition Pen Scanner.

    http://www.the-gadgeteer.com/review/i_r_i_s_irispen_express_text_recognition_pen_scanner

    Just click the POST REPLY button on this page.

    1
  • DStaal November 22, 2005, 5:17 pm

    That French scan isn’t flawless: the accents are messed up. (Missing on the ‘E’, wrong on the ‘i’. Sorry, I don’t know how to type them under OS/2…)

    2
  • Judie November 22, 2005, 5:47 pm

    Ha! Good catch…obviously I don’t par-lez vous fran-say.;)

    3
  • JohnKes November 22, 2005, 6:37 pm

    I noticed a lot of lariats in your signature – Cowgirl, huh?:
    http://www.inquiry.net/outdoor/spin_rope/throw_lariat.htm

    4
  • Judie November 22, 2005, 6:43 pm

    Ha! Are you making fun of my loopy signature? :D

    I honestly figured a graphologist would come on here at some point and have something to say about it. :p

    5
  • JohnKes November 22, 2005, 8:16 pm

    I’ve read a few books on handwriting …

    My best buddy Dave was into racquetball. His D had a little handle on it.
    My J is swept back, as a good aircraft leading edge should be (I am in the Aerospace business).
    I knew a guy who was very family oriented. He initialed his work with a big C surrounding his first initials. His last name was Carbajal.

    People seem put certain of their interests into their signatures.

    JK

    6
  • oopscdaz November 28, 2005, 7:24 am

    Not trying to make fun of anyone as your reviews on products are some of the best I have read…
    I have to admit however, that what was supposed to be scanned and what was scanned was the funniest post I have read in quite sometime! The product recognizes 55 languages and it seems as if some of those 55 appeared in the scan.. I could not help laughing as I have had the same problems with Calligrapher for Pocket PC…. I finally would end up just trying to print the letters and even that was to no avail…

    7
  • Judie November 28, 2005, 1:49 pm

    @oopscdaz – That’s quite all right! I got a good laugh seeing some of the results I got, too. ;)

    8
  • rmbraun123 January 3, 2006, 1:18 am

    Hi Julie. I was about to order the IRISPen but I read your review and … I did not. I am a poor typist and I am looking for a scanner to put into Word quotes from books I am reading in which I have the unfortunate habit to underline paragraphs, sentences or words that I may want to use as quotes at a later date. Sometimes I am just marking the paragraph in the margin though, which is probably a more practical way to do it for scanning. Do you have a suggestion for a usable scanner? I looked at a Cannon available for $50 on Amzon.com and also at Plustek Optiblock 3600 which at $250 would have to “walk on water” to merrit its price. Any help that you can, would, dedain or agree to give me? Thanks, Robert

    9
  • Judie January 3, 2006, 1:27 am

    Robert, it just so happens that Julie will be posting a review on another compact scanner, the docupen, this evening…
    I don’t know what she thinks of it yet, but it may be one to consider, or to mark off the list. :0)

    10
  • billtubbs January 7, 2007, 7:09 pm

    Hi Judie

    this is a great review. Comprehensively tackles the key issue of how effective these pens are at character recognition in practice. I wanted to use the pen to scan transaction details from receipts (name, amount, date etc).

    However, as others have said, I will refrain from buying one of these pens based on the less than 99% reliability of the scans. But could it just be that the IRIS Pen Express is not as good as other pen scanners (e.g. c-pen, Wizcom)? What is your opinion about that? My guess would be they all have a similar level of performance but I’d like to know what you think.

    Bill.

    11
  • jj9 May 7, 2007, 1:57 am

    Hi there, thank you for a great review!

    I have a question re: the IRISpen Executive Asian.

    Does it have any competitors that scan Japanese and translate into English? If anyone knows of any, if you can tell me, that will be a great help, thank you! The IRISpen Executive Asian is expensive, and from reviews, apparently causes some of the frustrations mentioned in this review. However, I live and work in Japan, and am learning Japanese, but am only beginning. Every day I receive many papers on my desk, in Japanese. So, a translating scanner might be so helpful that I am considering buying the Irispen Executive Asian, even with its high price and frustrations. Before I buy it, I would like to know if there are any other scanners available anywhere that scan Japanese characters and translate them into English, to make a choice of which scanner to purchase. So far, I have not been able to find any; some translate English into Japanese, but no others I can find translate Japanese into English. Thanks for your help!

    12
  • Karenet August 14, 2007, 8:11 pm

    Hi,
    I am a new member, could anyone tell me if the newly release irispen 6 this month is any better in accuracy and worht buying for?
    appreciate much
    :unsure:

    13
  • Ron December 13, 2007, 12:02 pm

    Great evaluation. Almost as good as trying the thing out for myself. The report being dated 2005, can you tell me if this was the IRISPen Express 6 ? Wondering if they improved their product since this report.

    thanks,

    Ron

    14
  • Alain February 4, 2009, 1:48 pm

    hi, I know if I need to scan tables like this one
    Choice 1 Choice 2 Choice 3
    Choice 1 1 2 3
    Choice 2 4 5 6
    Choice 3 7 8 9

    is it going to cause problems, the lines will they find a good place and towards the right information
    thank you

    15
  • Curious May 14, 2009, 9:22 am

    I take short handwritten notes when I read. Will the pen scan them accurately? Do you have suggestions? I’ve looked at tablets but most options are for PCs and I’m a Mac User.

    Thanks

    16
  • J.Vis May 22, 2009, 10:21 am

    The pen proved in my case to be a complete disaster. It neverw worked, during calibration I got the message ‘not connecte” and a pop-up appeared with the message debug bulkhead reader. I complained several times however I never got a reply from the factor in Belgium, however they acknowleged the receipt of my complaint. I would be very careful with this product and company.

    17
  • Evolution World June 10, 2010, 1:16 pm

    Is this pen also recognize hand writing ??

    18
  • Kylie June 25, 2010, 8:22 pm

    Hi Ron,

    This is not the irispen 6. If you look at the picture of the box it is a very old edition of the pen. I have been searching google and have seen a lot of reviews of this pen, such as http://www.irispenscanner.com , most of them are good reviews, saying the pen does exactly what is advertised. I can see how this old generation of pen would have some flaws. The best thing you can do is read up as much as you can about what the express 6 does and decided from there. Remember it takes some getting used to, like learning to hold it at the right angle etc. And if it is still not doing what you expect then you should send it back definitely.

    19
  • v. Otto December 6, 2010, 5:02 pm

    This pen is worthless, and worse than the fact that it will not work, is the fact that the 800# support redirects you to online queries, and then hangs up!

    When I called the sales department the man was rude and refused to offer any options.

    We are returning this product to the store.

    20
  • Ulin January 3, 2011, 12:16 am

    Will there be a version for the Android Platform. I want to use one on a Tablet PC.

    21
  • Govind January 10, 2011, 5:48 am

    How can buy iris pen scanner please tell me

    22

Leave a Comment